European football clubs continue to tie-up with India but ground results not visible yet
Despite the flurry of activities in recent years, including hosting the upcoming FIFA U-17 World Cup and the advent of ISL, an Indian team in the World Cup still remains a far-fetched dream
New Delhi: 'Tied up in knots' could be an apt summation of the plethora of tie-ups that Indian football witnessed with top European clubs in recent years, partnerships that seemed to be driven primarily by commerce, if experts are to be believed.
Notwithstanding the involvement of the biggest names in club football — FC Barcelona, PSG Saint Germain, Arsenal and Liverpool etc, these link-ups, most of them technical, have failed to inspire confidence as far as game development in the country is concerned.
Recently, Spanish club Atletico Madrid ended its association with Indian Super League franchise Atletico de Kolkata due to disagreements over youth development.
"These are all commercial ventures and has little impact on football development," says Shaji Prabhakaran, former FIFA regional development officer for South and Central Asia.
Prabhakaran has been involvement with the game for more than two decades and had worked at the All India Football Federation and Asian Football Confederations (AFC) before being appointed regional development officer of FIFA.
He added, "It's basically for elite people who can afford."
"Many of the country's promising talent, living in abject poverty in the deep interiors of the country, don't even know of such projects and will never be able to afford them. It's basically a branding exercise."
Despite the flurry of activities in recent years, including hosting the upcoming FIFA U-17 World Cup and the advent of ISL, an Indian team in the World Cup still remains a far-fetched dream though the country has a huge fan following for the beautiful game.
Realising the enthusiasm for the sport among Indian teenagers, Europe's biggest clubs have tied up with some leading schools in the country and set up training schools with private partners.
As part of a tie-up with DSK Shivajians, Liverpool FC set up a residential football coaching academy to develop players up to age 18.
Another EPL giant, Arsenal FC, has opened Arsenal Soccer Schools across the country.
"See, these tie-ups have their pros and cons. Football development is one area where we need technical support from them. We get very strong curriculum from them and coaches come and deliver these curriculum," says Vivek Sethia, founder and CEO, India On Track-Arsenal Soccer Schools.
But they are not able to leverage it well because of the "gap in talent", which is big.
"The gap is so huge, it becomes a huge challenge. But the positive thing is there is an exchange programme, like sending students there and getting experts from there," he adds.
Sethia agrees that it's a commercial partnership.
"It's a commercial partnership from our perspective but the fee is minimum, because they (European clubs) also look at burgeoning Indian market."
"Most of the clubs are okay as they can generate revenue from the commercial Indian market, talent is not the first priority right now."
"We are trying very hard to become relevant from talent perspective. We run both commercial and non commercial programs and also have scholarships programmes that are talent- based. The onus is on us, we don't have a footballing ecosystem and that is the biggest problem."
Neel Shah, CEO of DSK Shivajians, who have a partnership with English Premier League club Liverpool FC, feels the real test of any technical partnership is to see "how the programme is running" once the novelty factor wears off.
"My first recommendation for any group exploring a technical partnership with a top European club is to ensure both parties, the international club and the foreign partner, are clear on the short and long-term objectives and expectations of the project."
Shah adds, "My second recommendation is that the local partner ensures their senior Indian coaches buy into the idea of the technical partnership and their inputs on the deliverables are taken into account before finalising the agreement.
"Finally, it is critical to get the right person from the international club to come over to head the project. It is absolutely vital to have someone with solid character who can comfortably handle challenges and serve as a mentor for the local coaches."
Rajesh Mehrotra, director of PSG academy in India, emphasises on the three Cs - coach, culture and curriculum - in "no particular order".
According to him, India is still a long way off from having a good grassroot curriculum like developed football nations.
The British media were quick to turn their guns on the greed-motivated owners of the Premier League teams involved.
Premier League: Mikel Arteta unsure if injured Kieran Tierney will make another Arsenal appearance this season
The 23-year-old full-back limped off before half-time in a 3-0 Premier League loss at home to Jurgen Klopp's men on Saturday.
Even if this plan stumbles, the concept will be back, sooner rather than later, in some vaguely modified form. A superleague is, in effect, inevitable; European football has been drifting, inexorably, to this point for years.