War of words over Kashmir situation in Rajya Sabha: Amit Shah claims 'total normalcy' in Valley, Congress says HM referring to 'some other state'

New Delhi: Home Minister Amit Shah on Wednesday said in Rajya Sabha that total normalcy prevails in Kashmir with government offices and educational institutions functioning fully, but Internet connection will be restored after the local administration feels it is fit to do so. He also asserted that not a single person has died in police firing since 5 August when the Centre abrogated special status of the state although many feared there would be bloodshed and more killings. [caption id=“attachment_7679301” align=“alignleft” width=“380”]  Home Minister Amit Shah addresses Rajya Sabha. PTI[/caption] Prohibitory orders under Section 144 are prevalent only in certain areas from 8 pm to 6 am in the valley, he said. Responding to a series of questions on the situation in Jammu and Kashmir during Question Hour, Shah said government offices, educational institutes, courts, health centres, banks and media outlets are functioning fully. “As far as Internet service is concerned, an appropriate action will be taken on the recommendation of the local administration. Neighbouring country is still doing some mischief and we will restore the connection as soon as the local administration says it is fit to do so,” he said. Internet is important in the present day world and it should be restored as early as possible. It is an effective means of communication, he said. “However when it comes to the security of Jammu and Kashmir and for waging war against terrorism, we have to fix our priorities,” he said. The home minister recalled that it was the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government which began Internet service in Kashmir way back in 2002 and the mobile service in 2003. To a supplementary question on how much more time would be needed to bring normalcy in Kashmir, Shah said, “The situation there was always normal. There were many notions spread all over the world. There is total normalcy prevailing. After 5 August , not a single person has died in police firing although many feared there would be bloodshed and more number of killings.” All restrictions imposed in Kashmir have been successful. Stone pelting incidents have come down to 544 so far in 2019 from 802 incidents in 2018, he said. Highlighting the normal functioning of life in Kashmir, Shah said Urdu and English dailies and all TV channels are functioning and circulation of newspapers has increased. Courts are also functioning fully. They have heard 36,192 cases and delivered orders in as many as 500 cases, he said, adding that even the Block Development Council elections were held peacefully and successfully. He further said as many as 20,114 schools have opened. Out of 50,537 students, 50,272 students comprising 99.48 percent appeared for exams. About 99.7 percent of students have given Class 9 and 10 exams. Hospitals are also functioning and the number of people visiting the Out Patient Department (OPD) has increased in Srinagar, he said, adding good quantity of medicines are being made available in the Valley and there is no shortage. Mobile vans and vending machines were also made available. “If any one has information that a particular person in a remote area is not getting medical facility, they can contact me directly. I will get it done in 24 hours,” Shah told the House. The sale of LPG, kerosene and rice has also gone up by by 8-16 percent in the last ten years, he added. To protect apple growers, Shah said the government has made all arrangements for sale of the fruit. Cooperative NAFED has so far procured about 6,000 tonnes of apples from Kashmir. Apple production is estimated to be 22.58 lakh tonnes this year and the government is facilitating traders for sale of the fruit, he added. As the Home Minister gave out figures supporting normalcy in the Valley, Leader of Opposition in the Upper House, Ghulam Nabi Azad said, “It looks like the Home Minister is referring to the report of some other state.” When Opposition members objected to the Chair giving more time to the Home Minister to reply on Kashmir during the Question Hour, Chairman Venkaiah Naidu said, “It is a national security issue”. The Home Minister said, “there can be a discussion on this matter for an hour.” The Opposition insisted that there should a debate on the matter, to which Naidu said, “It will be done”.