The Accidental Prime Minister row: Rahul Gandhi and Congress in tough spot over free speech issue
The same Congress is now ignoring the 'freedom of speech' argument in the case of the upcoming film The Accidental Prime Minister.
Lending support to Jawaharlal Nehru University students in 2015 over the sedition row, the then Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi had tweeted:
Free speech is our right. We will fight any attempt to crush dissent and debate: Rahul Gandhi (2/2)
— Rahul Gandhi (@RahulGandhi) May 29, 2015
Again in July this year, Rahul, who by then had become the party’s president, came in support of the makers of the web series Sacred Games in which there are uncharitable references to his father and former prime minister Rajiv Gandhi for the latter’s alleged role in Bofors Scam and involvement in the Shah Bano case. The Congress president had tweeted:
BJP/RSS believe the freedom of expression must be policed & controlled. I believe this freedom is a fundamental democratic right.
My father lived and died in the service of India. The views of a character on a fictional web series can never change that.#SacredGames
— Rahul Gandhi (@RahulGandhi) July 14, 2018
But the same Congress is now ignoring the 'freedom of speech' argument in the case of the upcoming film The Accidental Prime Minister. The Maharashtra Youth Congress has asked the producers of the film — based on former prime minister Manmohan Singh — to first screen the film for them and delete or change certain scenes if found 'objectionable'.
What makes the youth wing of the Congress behave like the Karni Sena, the group that went hammer and tongs against the screening of the Hindi film Padmaavat? And why is the Congress stand different for this film when compared to that on Udta Punjab, which highlighted the drug menace in the state then ruled by Shiromani Akali Dal and BJP?
It's not hard to see why.
Unlike the past, The Accidental Prime Minister is apparently a frontal attack on Sonia and Rahul Gandhi. The film is based on a 2014 book An Accidental Prime Minister: The Making and Unmaking of Manmohan Singh by Sanjay Baru, who was Singh's media adviser from May 2004 to August 2008. The movie is supposed to be an insider's account of the dynamics of the Gandhi family vis-a-vis their role in Congress party and the then UPA government.
Bollywood rarely takes the incumbent establishment head on and references almost always remain oblique. Current and active political leaders are rarely brought alive on screen with nothing masking their identities. And history is often portrayed in great retrospect, rarely — if ever — within a few years of its making. It's important to note that Sonia and Rahul Gandhi will be testing their personal as well as their party's luck in the 2019 general elections and the film, with its reach, can affect their chances.
It's not mere coincidence that veteran actor Anupam Kher, who is avowedly pro-BJP with his wife and actor Kirron Kher being a BJP MP, is essaying the role of Manmohan Singh.
“Looking at the trailer of the movie, it’s understood that facts have been played with and presented in incorrect manner with regards to the ex-PM Resp Manmohan Singh ji, UPA chairperson Resp Sonia Gandhi ji and to malign the image of Congress party which is not acceptable,” Satyajeet Tambe Patil, president, Maharashtra State Youth Congress, wrote in his letter to the producers of the film.
“If the said movie is released with prior screening for our office bearers and without making necessary changes recommended by us, it’ll be understood that you are doing this deliberately…we’ve other options open to stop screening of the same across India…,” Patil said.
It seems films are the latest means for political parties to gain traction, and even settle political scores, if possible.
The 2016 film Udta Punjab was a case in point. The film dealt with the drug menace in the state that was ruled by the Akali Dal-BJP combine when it was released, giving enough meat to the Opposition to rub it in for the ruling government.
Rahul had then said of the film, “Punjab has a crippling drug problem. Censoring Udta Punjab will not fix it. The government must accept the reality and find solutions.”
Rahul's statement had got backing from the Aam Aadmi Party chief and Delhi chief minister Arvind Kejriwal.
However, unlike Patil, who is a state-level leader of Youth Congress with hardly any national recall, the senior leaders of Congress are maintaining a calculative silence over the issue.
Meanwhile, the new Congress government in Madhya Pradesh has clarified that no ban has been imposed on the film in the state. It’ll be interesting to see how the Congress president reacts on the issue or whether he asks his party workers and office bearers not to issue controversial statements that would indirectly benefit the BJP.
"Questions raised on India's democracy an insult to citizens": PM Modi hits back at Rahul Gandhi
PM Modi's retort followed Rahul's recent lecture at the prestigious Cambridge University where he claimed that the basic structure of the Indian democracy was under attack
Meet Purnesh Modi, the man whose defamation complaint led to Rahul Gandhi’s two-year sentence
Purnesh Modi is a BJP MLA and ex-Gujarat minister. The 57-year-old, who, joined the BJP in 1984, has held several positions within the party including its Surat city chief. Purnesh was in December 2022 among a slew of big names dropped from the Bhupendra Patel cabinet
Rahul Gandhi’s London diatribe, Khalistani assaults and the politics of India’s subversion by Anglo-Americans
Many of the UK’s prominent parliamentarians constantly provide ideological succour to both Khalistani and Islamist terror from constituencies across the whole of Britain