Rs 500, Rs 1,000 ban: Arvind Kejriwal is right, if Sanjeev Kamboj knew of demonetisation, it is a 'scam'

Kejriwal has put doubts in our minds. True to his usual shoot and scoot style, he may not produce hard evidence of all that he alleged

Akshaya Mishra November 12, 2016 15:16:49 IST
Rs 500, Rs 1,000 ban: Arvind Kejriwal is right, if Sanjeev Kamboj knew of demonetisation, it is a 'scam'

Trust Arvind Kejriwal to ask uncomfortable questions. Always first off the block to seek answers from the government, more specifically from Prime Minister Narendra Modi, he has done it again. This time the issue is demonetisation. And some of his stinging questions make sense.

If some outsider was in possession of a currency note worth Rs 2,000 before it made its public appearance, then the conclusion is as simple as it is harsh: The entire population of the country, which trusted the government has been taken for a royal ride. If bank deposits swelled in anticipation of demonetisation, meaning hoarders of black money had prior information about the change and had enough time to load stashed money into bank accounts, then it means nothing short of betrayal of public faith.

Rs 500 Rs 1000 ban Arvind Kejriwal is right if Sanjeev Kamboj knew of demonetisation it is a scam

File photo of Arvind Kejriwal. AFP

Total secrecy is vital to any such exercise. The purpose is to catch black money hoarders off-guard, leave them with no time to react. If Sanjeev Kamboj, BJP leader from Punjab, did post a picture of the new Rs 2,000 note before 8 November, it means a whole lot of people, at least in the BJP circles, were privy to the information of a demonetisation plan. It is not improbable that the information would have been passed on to many hoarders. This makes many Indians queuing up at banks and ATMs, sacrificing their daily work and maybe wages, to withdraw or exchange money absolute foolish. The demonetisation exercise is thus, as Kejriwal puts it, a 'scam'.

Kejriwal has put doubts in our minds. True to his usual shoot and scoot style, he may not produce hard evidence of all that he alleged. It's the responsibility of the government to refute him and explain to people what happened, both in the case of Kamboj and bank deposits. It has to come out with bank deposit details of the July-September quarter and convince us that the additional deposit, if there's some, is not due to spurious money taken out from lockers at homes. Kamboj may claim the picture he posted was not of the real note. But then the fact that he knew something about new currency notes is a serious matter. The BJP cannot escape by calling all allegations baseless.

Now that Kejriwal has dropped the bomb, politics will take over. The new currency issue hits political parties the hardest because most of their illegal poll-time transactions are conducted in cash of high denomination. Prior knowledge of demonetisation gives unfair advantage to the party or parties who have it. Some commentators have said that the Samajwadi Party in poll-bound Uttar Pradesh will be particularly hit and the fallout of demonetisation suits the BJP well. Expect harsh reaction from it and others.

It is surprising that the Congress saw no hint of foul play in the whole demonetisation matter. Even P Chidambaram, former finance minister, made no remark to this effect while criticising the government's move. It's to be seen whether the party rallies itself on the issue to take on the government.

Updated Date:

also read

Teenage terrorist's life casts light on Kashmiri Generation Alpha jihad
India

Teenage terrorist's life casts light on Kashmiri Generation Alpha jihad

Although these numbers are small compared to the 1990s, they show the long jihad which has shaped Kashmir’s history isn’t about to go away

Farm Laws Saga: A tactical retreat, civil society claims and the sad life of ‘andolanjeevis’
India

Farm Laws Saga: A tactical retreat, civil society claims and the sad life of ‘andolanjeevis’

The rollback shows how politically difficult it is to carry out economic reforms in India. In the prime minister's words, the government failed to convince a section of farmers about the benefits of the bill.

PM urges banks to support wealth and job creators, work proactively to improve India's balance sheet
India

PM urges banks to support wealth and job creators, work proactively to improve India's balance sheet

The prime minister also said that the recently set up National Asset Reconstruction Co (NARCL) would help resolve Rs 2 lakh crore of stressed assets