Rahul Gandhi's Karnataka 'peace rally' may be too little, too late to save Congress-JD(S) alliance from disaster
At the Saturday rally, in Karnataka, Rahul brought the squabbling Congress and JD(S) leaders on the dais for a photo op, but it didn't appear to have any unifying effect.
Since the Congress-JD(S) alliance was cobbled up, almost not a day has passed without its leaders taking potshots at each other.
Even now, days before the state goes to the polls, senior leaders are not undertaking joint campaigns against the BJP.
Rahul can only blame himself for not taking into account the local animosities between the parties while stitching up the alliance.
Rahul Gandhi may be remembered by posterity as the Antoni Gaudí of Indian politics. Antoni, who died in 1926, was a marvellous architect who made Spain proud. But he is also known for the "world's most notorious unfinished project". Work on the Sagrada Familia Church in Barcelona, which began in 1882, was abandoned and resumed so many times that it is expected to be completed only in 2026, the centenary of Antoni's death. Some say even that is doubtful. It's not surprising that it has been called a work "permanently" in progress.
Rahul's predilection for starting and abandoning political projects is an unmistakable hallmark of his career. Take, for instance, the way he surrounded himself with the awesome troika of Hardik Patel, Jignesh Mevani and Alpesh Thakor during the December 2017 Gujarat Assembly election, giving the BJP a fright. It was hailed as Rahul's political 'arangetram'. But the Congress chief abandoned this "social engineering", and Thakor has now abandoned Congress.
Exactly a year later, in December 2018, it was claimed that Rahul had masterminded the Congress victories in the Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh Assembly elections. The chest-thumping that ensued prompted the Left intellectuals and admirers of the Nehru-Gandhi clan to write out the obituary of the Narendra Modi government. But Rahul wasted the opportunity like a child smashing his favourite toy on the floor in sheer joy.
Between these two alleged accomplishments came another in Karnataka. In May 2018, he brought the Congress and Janata Dal (Secular) together, in what might be an alliance that was rustled up in the shortest time in India's history. Rahul's admirers claimed that the sagacity he exhibited surpassed the combined wisdom of Chanakya and Confucius. Then after the alliance formed the government in Karnataka, he abandoned it to live its own life or die its own death — he didn't seem to care which.
Peace rally in troubled area
Having achieved its primary purpose of keeping the BJP out of power, the alliance has since remained, like Antoni's church, a work "permanently" in progress. Some might argue that as the president of the Congress, Rahul himself is a work in progress. The coalition has been bumbling along like a blind man who lost his cane. Since it was cobbled up, almost not a day has passed without leaders of the JD(S) and Congress taking potshots at each other, starting with squabbling over distribution of posts to allocation of tickets for the Lok Sabha election to be held in the state on 18 and 23 April (phases 2 and 3).
Even with four days to go for the first day of polling in 14 of Karnataka's 28 Lok Sabha seats, senior leaders of both parties are spending more time preaching unity to workers than undertaking joint campaigns against the BJP.
It was in this context that Rahul picked Krishnarajanagara in Karnataka to address an election rally on Saturday, apparently on the advice of Chief Minister HD Kumaraswamy to bring peace to the warring parties. Krishnarajanagara is in Mysuru district but is part of the Mandya constituency, where the chief minister's son and 29-year-old budding actor Nikhil Kumaraswamy is a candidate of the Congress-JD(S) alliance. Mandya also happens to be among the seats where the shadow-boxing between the two parties is most appalling.
Madness in Maddur
Pitted against Nikhil is Sumalatha, an actress and the wife of popular Kannada film star Ambareesh who died five months ago. Ambareesh had won the seat twice earlier on a Congress ticket and was a minister in the UPA government. After the Congress denied her a ticket, Sumalatha decided to contest as an Independent, and that's when things went further downhill. Sumalatha is getting support from not only the BJP, which has not a fielded a candidate of its own there, but also from sections of the Congress who are refusing to back Nikhil.
The resistance in one party of the alliance to work for the candidate of the other is quite brazen in southern Karnataka, where both have strong bases and have been dog-eat-dog sort of rivals for long. This has been rightly seen as no more than vicious animosity between Kumaraswamy and his father HD Deve Gowda of the JD(S) on one side and senior Congress leader and former chief minister Siddaramaiah on the other, with both sides fighting for political supremacy in the region. This naturally translates into a tussle between Deve Gowda's upper-caste Vokkaligas and Siddaramaiah's backward caste of Kurubas.
However, Deve Gowda and Siddaramaiah have been sharing dais the past few days to put up a facade of unity, but nobody is fooled. In an interview to Firstpost, Siddaramaiah was candid enough to admit that the hostilities between workers of the two parties were natural because practically every village in the region was vertically divided into Congress and JD(S) camps. But he downplayed the whole scenario, saying the rivalry was confined to the three districts of Hassan, Mandya and Mysuru.
The fiasco of the alliance may not end in a statewide electoral catastrophe for the two parties, but it may be sufficiently disastrous, with leaders of the two parties not ruling out some of their votes going to the BJP. Rahul can only blame himself for not having taken into account and dealt with the local animosities while stitching up the alliance.
At the Saturday rally, Rahul, once again, brought the squabbling senior leaders on the dais for a photo op. But for all the effect it had on unifying middle-level leaders and workers, the Congress chief might as well have addressed a rally in Nicaragua.
And if past experience is anything to go by, the current show of unity is just a bubble waiting to burst at the slightest prick of a provocation.
The author tweets @sprasadindia
Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.
"The real danger to India isn't that our prime minister doesn't understand. It's the fact that nobody has the guts to tell him," Rahul said on Twitter, attaching a video clip of Narendra Modi suggesting use of wind turbines to produce oxygen
At a campaign meeting on Sunday in Gwalior's Dabra town, where the BJP has fielded Imarti Devi, Kamal Nath had said the Congress candidate was a "simple person" unlike his opponent who was an "item".
The Congress leaders made the comments in reference to reports of a BJP MLA and his son allegedly taking away a man accused of harassing a woman from police custody on Saturday