Here is a picture from the late 1970s: Then prime minister Indira Gandhi calls on an ailing Sheikh Abdullah at a hospital in Srinagar. He had just been released and had taken the reins of the state after elections. The picture shows Indira offering her hand while Abdullah is lying in bed. Yet, the persona of the man, a veteran leader from Jawaharlal Nehru's generation, towered over that of Indira's.
Here is another image, this time from Wednesday: Congress general secretary Priyanka Gandhi visits Bhim Army chief Chandrashekhar Azad at a Meerut hospital. The indisposed Dalit activist remained resting in his bed, as Priyanka sat in a chair next to him and her associates stood by.
The two images are decades — and generations — apart, but compare them and the contrast in the balance of power between a pair of leaders stands out. The latest one will haunt the Congress party in general and the Nehru-Gandhi family in particular for years to come.
The picture speaks eloquently of the desperation in the Congress to revive the moribund social support for the party in the country's most populous state, Uttar Pradesh. In the Congress' assessment, Azad is a foil to Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) and its supremo Mayawati. That a member of the first family of the Congress chose to meet Azad, a young leader with not-so-formidable credentials is a seminal signal of the dynasty's decline.
The assumption that Azad and his motley crew can substitute Mayawati and the BSP in Uttar Pradesh politics is patently erroneous on many counts. Before the BSP came to symbolise Dalit assertion in the state, it had done its groundwork on a mammoth scale. The formation of various bodies like the Dalit Shoshit Samaj Sangharsh Samiti (DS4) and The All India Backward And Minority Communities Employees Federation (BAMCEF) was a formidable exercise in organisation-building long before the BSP came into full existence. Of course, Kanshi Ram, a visionary leader, was the brains behind these exercises that laid the foundation for a strong Dalit political force.
Azad, at best, can be seen as a rabble-rouser in the state's context, not a serious political contender. Priyanka's visit will no doubt give him legitimacy, but it will thoroughly erode her credibility. At the same time, such a visual will bring all efforts of the Congress to win over the upper castes to nought. In the state, the Congress was essentially seen as a party of Brahmins who form a sizable chunk of the electorate at nearly 11 percent.
Imagine Priyanka calling on Mayawati or Mulayam Singh Yadav, with sufficient deference to their age and stature, and the equation would have been different. It would have been quite similar to Indira calling on an ailing Abdullah. But Priyanka's photo with Azad is a poor strategy by all reckoning.
Perhaps a novice when it comes to politics, Priyanka may not be aware of how powerful an image can be in influencing the course of political history. Her father Rajiv Gandhi snubbed the then Andhra Pradesh chief T Anjaiah at Hyderabad airport — and it led to the creation of a formidable anti-Congress force under the leadership of NT Rama Rao. The Congress decimation in Uttar Pradesh was preceded by successive humiliation and marginalisation of chief ministers like Sripati Mishra, ND Tiwari and Bir Bahadur Singh in the 1980s and 1990s by the members of the dynasty. In those times, Sanjay Gandhi and subsequently Rajiv could get away with this cockiness because of the party's undisputed dominance over the polity.
In today's times, the situation has completely changed. In Uttar Pradesh, the Congress has been reduced to the margins of the state's politics, probably competing with sub-regional parties in terms of the support base.
No doubt the Congress still retains a group of highly-committed workers on the ground who can mobilise people in its favour. Similarly, there are enough follies committed by the BJP that may force a significant section of voters to look for an alternative at the national level. The Congress obviously then fits the bill. But the party appears to be lacking singularly in evolving a coherent strategy to pose even a challenge to its rivals like BJP and the Samajwadi Party-BSP combine.
The Grand Old Party of India seems to be surrendering much before the game has actually begun. If there is any doubt, a cursory glance at the picture of Priyanka standing by the side of a resting Azad would set it to rest.
Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and news updates, sign up for our WhatsApp services. Just go to Firstpost.com/Whatsapp and hit the Subscribe button.
Updated Date: Mar 14, 2019 19:59:50 IST