Narendra Modi's second term in office: From job creation, tax rates to agrarian crisis, to-do list for next five years is ready
The Narendra Modi government should work on getting state finances in order
At the broader level, the government has to focus on the small and medium-sized enterprises (SME) segment and start-ups
At the corporate level, the corporate tax rate has to be lowered for sure or can be linked with investments
The financial system has to be made more robust and the approach to banks and NPAs has to be made clear
Giving suggestions to the new government on what should be done to keep the economy going may sound pompous given that there are experienced experts working on the same in various ministries and advisory bodies. Therefore, any thoughts on what should be done are more in the form of expectations from the new government rather than suggestions.
It is quite clear that the economy is definitely going through odd times. Odd, because while we still take pride in claiming to be the fastest growing economy in the world for the last few years, there are several zones of discomfort which call for some policy action. In fact, the recent controversy on the economic data releases has cast elements of a shadow on some economic variables. Whichever way one looks at the performance of the economy, there are definitely areas of improvement that should be on the priority list.
The first pressing issue in the country today is employment. It is evident that the pace of jobs creation has not kept up with gross domestic product (GDP) growth that has been in the region of 7 percent per annum. While it is true that most jobs are created in the private sector which is dependent on growth which makes the reasoning circular, the government can focus on areas which increase the demand for labour. To begin with, the empty posts in the government offices have to be filled up so that there is optimal capacity utilisation here.
At the broader level, the government has to focus on the small and medium-sized enterprises (SME) segment and start-ups where individuals can find employment by partly becoming entrepreneurs. Even today there are schemes which have been started for start-ups. The way forward is to have an end-to-end solution where the Centre works with the states to ensure that starting a business becomes easy from registration, property acquisition, tax compliance, labour rules, etc. Maybe a single window clearance should be in place.
The second pressing issue today relates to consumption which is down. It can partly be attributed to a lower number of jobs that have been created. Can the government do anything here?
In the USA we have seen that the government has gone in for tax cuts to kick-start the economy while here in India a tough call has to be taken. Tax cuts are needed in the middle and higher ends of income because this is where there is spending power.
GST rates need to be reviewed and here too, any rationalisation can mean a loss of revenue. Therefore, the tax rates need to be changed effectively to ensure that spending power improves without seriously distorting the collections. It has to be done in a calibrated manner so that as tax rates are cut, consumption leads to higher growth which generates more revenue—the classical case of supply-side economics working a la Laffer curve theory.
At the corporate level, the corporate tax rate has to be lowered for sure or can be linked with investments so that the issue of capital formation can also be addressed. This is the investment push that can be provided as presently the government appears to be more focused on the capex which gets restricted to roads, housing and to an extent, urban development. For it to be more encompassing, corporates have to be encouraged to invest more. Investment can be the third main focus area and the private sector being the trigger.
The fourth sector that has to be targeted is agriculture. There has been a tendency for a piecemeal approach to be followed for farming as there are multiple entities involved as agriculture is a state subject. This is one reason as to why an end-to-end solution does not exist. The problems start from land, seeds, irrigation, yields, credit, sale, logistics (transport and warehousing), marketing and packaging. As states also get involved, there are varied interest groups which have made the system cumbersome and not free-flowing.
The Green Revolution worked in the late 60s and 70s in enhancing yields because there was a clear agenda focused on wheat which had a frontend procurement process. But farming is more complex given the scale and hence just creating an electronic national agricultural market without APMC laws being effectively repealed does not work. Some states have abolished them but others haven’t. Also, road connectivity is absent in rural areas as the centre has focused mainly on highways and left the rural connectivity to states. There is hence a need to have this integrated approach to make the system resilient.
A project that must be taken up is the channelling of the rivers down the sub-continent to ensure that access to irrigation is available in the regions that are susceptible to monsoon inconsistencies. This has to again get the acceptance of states because in drought-prone areas it would be good if perennial rivers like the Ganges are channelled to these segments.
Fifth, the financial system has to be made more robust and the approach to banks and NPAs has to be made clear. The resolution process has been fairly uneven with different strictures being in force. A concerted action plan drawn with the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has to be in place in the short-term so that there is a clear direction for the banks as well as borrowers and the path to resolution is transparent.
It has also been seen that while the central government manages the fiscal situation quite well, it is not the same with all the states. The government should work in getting state finances in order and leave it to a high-level committee to actually recommend certain limits that can be put for states finances in order to have more discipline. This is necessary as getting higher growth cannot be done by the Centre on its own and requires a lot of support from states as the structure is federal in scope.
The above-mentioned five to six points can be the focus for the government for the first 365 days so as to strengthen the foundations of the economy.
(The writer is Chief Economist, CARE Ratings)
Afghan crisis: Top Russian security official General Nikolay Patrushev visits India to discuss strategy
National security advisor Ajit Doval invited General Nikolay Patrushev after a Modi-Putin conversation on 24 August. The MEA said the two leaders had expressed the view that it was important for the two strategic partners to work together
According to global leader approval tracker Morning Consult, the prime minister's peak rating of 84 percent was in May 2020
The daily COVID-19 vaccinations crossed the one-crore mark for the fourth time in less than a month on Friday — the other days being 6 September, 31 August and 27 August