Exclusive videos: The truth about Naxal justice & injustice

There is no unified theme behind the war on Naxalism launched by India's states. Little wonder they aren't achieving much

hidden June 28, 2011 10:14:47 IST

Special to Firstpost

Is the war against the Maoists proceeding according to plan? Or, is there a plan at all?

To find out, Firstpost commissioned THL Mediagrove to make contact with the Maoists and the government forces battling them in two of the eastern states—Bihar and Jharkhand—to get a clearer view from ground zero.

Exclusive videos The truth about Naxal justice  injustice

The war may be meandering into a stalemate, thanks to uncoordinated actions by various state forces, and a more cohesive approach from the rebel forces. Reuters

What is clear from their interactions—the first in recent months—is that the war may be meandering into a stalemate, thanks to uncoordinated actions by various state forces, and a more cohesive approach from the rebel forces. In Jharkhand, the drive to catch a key Maoist commander has got nowhere despite several attempts.

While the Maoists—also known as Naxals—seem to be preparing for a long-drawn war against the state, the state does not seem to be getting anywhere.

The Naxals plan has three prongs—try and show the people that they are the benefactors by dispensing medicine and food, enforce rudimentary justice, including Taliban-style kangaroo courts, and three, indoctrinate all its recruits—including women—with its ideology. The whole edifice is supported by extortion from businessmen and traders.

The government counter-move is uncoordinated, and lacking in rigour – as it is evident from the lack of success in cornering the rebels and gaining territory now under Naxal sway (See video of how the Jharkhand government has failed to capture its most wanted Naxal enemy despite many efforts).

As Ajai Sahni, Executive Director of the Institute of Conflict Management and the South Asia Terrorism Portal, points out, the only state to register some success in its war against Naxals is Andhra Pradesh.

The rest are not even talking in one voice. While Chhattisgarh is firm that the Naxals can only be defeated by force, it has not been able to project its forces effectively. In fact, the security forces in Chhattisgarh have been more at the receiving end of Naxal violence.

In Bihar, Chief Minister Nitish Kumar is not keen on a solution by force, even though his police chief thinks it is needed. In West Bengal, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has been given a little time by the Maoists to withdraw central forces from some areas, which she has pledged to do.

THL Mediagrove journalists VK Shashikumar, Shankar Kumar, Nidhi Bhardwaj and Suraj have reported this video story.

Updated Date:

Subscribe to Moneycontrol Pro at ₹499 for the first year. Use code PRO499. Limited period offer. *T&C apply

also read

'Don't look at West Bengal through saffron lenses': Mamata Banerjee questions rationale behind 8-phase polls
India

'Don't look at West Bengal through saffron lenses': Mamata Banerjee questions rationale behind 8-phase polls

Banerjee also took exception over the EC appointing two special police observers for West Bengal, Vivek Dubey and MK Das

West Bengal polls: 'Support Mamata', Tejashwi Yadav tells Biharis in state ahead of Assembly elections
Politics

West Bengal polls: 'Support Mamata', Tejashwi Yadav tells Biharis in state ahead of Assembly elections

After a meeting with Mamata Banerjee at the state secretariat in Kolkata, the RJD leader said that the first priority of his party was to stop the BJP's progress in West Bengal

West Bengal polls: Left, Congress and ISF finalise seat-sharing deal for first two phases
Politics

West Bengal polls: Left, Congress and ISF finalise seat-sharing deal for first two phases

Reports suggest that the Left Front will walk away with the largest chunk of 165 out of the 294 seats, leaving Congress with 92 and ISF with 37, but a final announcement is likely later this week