Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas? Not so much, claims study: Four of five best-governed states in India not BJP-ruled

The four South Indian states were the top four among the 18 large states in the Public Affairs Index, followed by BJP-governed Gujarat and Maharashtra.

IndiaSpend July 25, 2018 19:38:54 IST
Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas? Not so much, claims study: Four of five best-governed states in India not BJP-ruled

By Shreehari Paliath

Mumbai: The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), or a political alliance it is a part of, governs 18 of the 29 states in India, home to nearly 63% of the country’s population. But only one BJP-ruled state, Himachal Pradesh, made it to the list of five best-governed states in India, according to a new study.

The Public Affairs Index (PAI) 2018 developed by the Public Affairs Centre (PAC), a Bengaluru-based think tank, evaluated state governance using 10 broad themes, 30 focus subjects and 100 indicators, according to its website. These include law and order, economic freedom, environment, transparency and so on. This is the third edition of the index. The previous ones can be found here and here.

Sabka Saath Sabka Vikas Not so much claims study Four of five bestgoverned states in India not BJPruled

People gathered at a Narendra Modi rally. Image Courtesy: Flickr/Narendra Modi

The top five states in the order of their ranking are Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Telangana, Himachal Pradesh and Karnataka. Of these, Kerala is governed by the Communist Party of India (Marxist)-led Left Democratic Front, Tamil Nadu by the All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (AIADMK), Telangana by the Telangana Rashtra Samiti (TRS) and Karnataka by a Janata Dal (Secular)-Congress combine.

The top 10 list includes all the southern states — none of which are governed by the BJP. Four states in this list are governed by the BJP and two by its chief opponent, the Congress (singly or in a coalition). Andhra Pradesh, ruled by the Telugu Desam Party, was placed ninth.

These ranks are significant because BJP came to power on the promise of delivering development through its Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas (development for all) campaign.

“The election manifesto, which revolves around the core issues of good governance and development, discusses in detail the party’s focus on tackling the concerns of price rise, corruption, black money and policy paralysis,” noted the prime minister’s website the day his party’s election manifesto was released on 7 April, 2014.

The PAI index has ranked 30 states, including Delhi. The aggregated rankings of the the top two states — Kerala and Tamil Nadu — have remained the same over three years. “These [southern] states have been doing well historically,” Narayana A, faculty on governance at Azim Premji University, told IndiaSpend. “It may not be the presence or absence of the BJP that matters so much. The nature of politics may be a factor like the mobilisation of other backward classes and scheduled castes states like Kerala and Tamil Nadu.” An enlightened or politically active population puts pressure on governments to perform better, he added. Himachal Pradesh best among small states Himachal Pradesh topped the list of small states. A state is classified as “small” if its population is less than 20 million. Of the 12 small states that made it to the list, BJP heads, or is a part of, the government in eight. Goa and Tripura made it to the top five. The non-BJP exception is the Congress-led government in Mizoram, placed third after Goa and Sikkim. Among the 18 large states (with population over 20 million), the top four were South Indian states, followed by BJP-governed Gujarat and Maharashtra. Bihar languished at the bottom in the list of large states and the overall aggregated ranking. Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh were the other states at the bottom of the PAI index for large states. All the bottom four large states are BJP-governed.

BJP-governed states, led by Gujarat, have most economic freedom

“The theme of economic freedom explores the effort undertaken by the state governments to improve the business environment in the state,” the report said.

Gujarat topped the list of five states that offer the most economic freedom, while Maharashtra was ranked second. Telangana, placed third before Himachal Pradesh and Haryana, was the only state without a BJP government in this category.

“BJP has come to symbolise the economic and political right. They want to present the party as one which promotes business, which makes it easy for investments to come in,” said Narayana.

The southern states may not do as well as Gujarat in ease of doing or promoting business, but Tamil Nadu and Karnataka have done well in attracting foreign direct investment, Narayana pointed out. States like Jharkhand and Madhya Pradesh just provide land or speedy clearances, but that makes for only “selective good governance”, he said.

India jumped 30 notches up in the top 100 rankings on the World Bank’s ‘ease of doing business’ index, thanks to major improvements in indicators such as resolving insolvency, paying taxes, protecting minority investors and getting credit, The Hindu Business Line reported on 31 October, 2017.

Gujarat has consistently been ranked first for economic freedom since the PAI was first published in 2016. Bihar was ranked last among the large states on this aspect.

Delhi, Tripura fare poorly in law and order

Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Maharashtra (in that order) have the best record in managing crime and maintaining law and order among the large states. Haryana and Jharkhand rank the last in this list. The top five safest states feature two BJP-ruled states, including Gujarat, and three governed by others, including West Bengal.

This theme explored violence, atrocities and policing, including indicators such as rapes, murder and dowry deaths per 1,00,000 population, among other factors.

As many as 39 crimes against women were reported every hour in India, up from 21 in 2007, according to the Crime in India 2016 report by the National Crime Records Bureau, IndiaSpend reported on 12 December, 2017.

“It is interesting to point out that despite Kerala having a very high number of FIRs, it has performed well in the matter of their disposal and conviction rate,” the report noted. “The reason for such high number of crimes reported has been explained by senior police officers of the state as arising out of awareness and social aggression; it cannot be denied that this is an indicator of high trust in the police as an institution.”

Nagaland and Goa were the best among small states, while Delhi and Tripura were at the bottom in this list. These two states have been at the bottom across the three years of the PAI. Nagaland was the best-performing as per the aggregated ranking of 30 states.

The number of rapes reported each year in Delhi has more than tripled over five years to 2016, registering an increase of 277 percent from 572 in 2011 to 2,155 in 2016, according to data released by the Delhi Police, IndiaSpend reported on 8 July, 2017.

Delhi at the bottom on environment and transparency

Delhi, governed by the Aam Aadmi Party, is placed last in the list on two counts — environment, and transparency and accountability.

Air quality in Delhi is at ‘hazardous’ levels, with areas in the national capital registering an air quality index value — a composite measure of ozone, nitrogen dioxide, sulphur dioxide and particulate pollution — of 999 on 13 June, 2018, according to the World Air Quality Index, IndiaSpend reported on 18 June, 2018.

Globally, India fared poorly in terms of environmental health. It is now among the bottom five countries on the Environmental Performance Index 2018, plummeting 36 points from 141 in 2016, The Hindu reported on 24 January, 2018.

Karnataka emerged as the best in the category among large states while Arunachal Pradesh was placed on top among small states. “The two states that stand out are Gujarat, which has fallen seven ranks from the last three years to 10 now, and Telangana, which has improved its position from 17 last year to 7 this year,” the report noted.

Transparency and accountability included indicators such as services provided under the e-governance plan, anti-corruption cases disposed as a percentage of total cases registered, and social audit under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act.

Karnataka and Haryana were the top two states on the transparency scale. Kerala fell eight places to 11th among the large states in this respect between 2017 and 2018. But Telangana’s ranking improved seven spots to fourth during the same period.

Updated Date:

also read

Indore to Tirupati to Ujjain: How old cities, temple towns are turning icons of cleanliness

Indore to Tirupati to Ujjain: How old cities, temple towns are turning icons of cleanliness

Narendra Modi’s Swachh Bharat Mission, once mocked by many as a silly, unattainable campaign unworthy of a PM, seems to be slowly bearing fruit. Old cities and pilgrim towns, which once seemed like basket cases when it comes to cleanliness, are now leading the way for the rest of the nation.

Farm laws repealed but fate of protesting farmers with FIR against them still unclear

Farm laws repealed but fate of protesting farmers with FIR against them still unclear

Sources in Delhi police maintained that investigation will go on in these cases. Charges even include anti-terror UAPA sections in some instances

Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Mukti Yodhas to attend 1971 war victory celebrations at India Gate from 14-16 December

Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Mukti Yodhas to attend 1971 war victory celebrations at India Gate from 14-16 December

The war had ended on 16 December after Pakistani troops surrendered to Indian troops. By taking 93,000 Pakistani prisoners of war, the Indian Army created a record of sorts as this was the biggest ever military defeat in recent history