Explained: AAP’s new battle with L-G VK Saxena… this time over Delhi buses
The latest tussle between the AAP government and Lieutenant Governor VK Saxena is over alleged irregularities in the purchase of 1,000 buses by the Delhi Transport Corporation. The Delhi government dismissed claims of wrongdoing, saying it was an attempt by the L-G to deflect people's attention
The Arvind Kejriwal-led Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) government in Delhi faces trouble once again and this time it’s over the purchase of 1,000 low-floor buses by the Delhi Transport Corporation (DTC).
On Sunday, Delhi’s Lieutenant Governor (L-G) VK Saxena approved a proposal to forward a complaint to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) to probe the alleged corruption in the procurement of the DTC buses.
The matter quickly became a political dogfight with the AAP alleging that the L-G was levelling fake and baseless corruption charges against the Delhi government just to deflect public attention from the corruption charges against him.
The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), the main opposition, also chimed in saying that Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal and corruption had become synonymous and demanded his resignation.
Let’s take a closer look at the purported bus scam that has been committed and how the parties reacted to the situation.
The DTC bus ‘scam’
The L-G recommendation for a CBI probe into the matter is based off a complaint in June that alleged irregularities in the appointment of the Delhi transport minister as chairman of the committee related to tendering and purchase of DTC buses.
It also said the appointment of the Delhi Integrated Multi-Modal Transit System (DIMTS) as the management consultant for the tender was done with the aim of facilitating irregularities in the purchase.
According to news agency PTI, the complaint is pertaining to a July 2019 procurement bid for 1,000 low floor BS-IV and BS-VI buses and another bid made in March 2020 for the purchase and annual maintenance contract for low floor BS-VI buses. It alleged irregularities in both these deals.
From here, the complaint was forwarded to the Chief Secretary on 22 July and was then submitted to the L-G on 19 August, after certain irregularities were found.
As per the Chief Secretary’s report, there were gross violations of the Central Vigilance Commission’s guidelines and general financial rules. It also added that the DIMTS was deliberately made a consultant so that the discrepancies in the tender process could be endorsed.
The discrepancy in the document read, “The DTC had floated the tender with RFP No CGM/SBU/924/2019/AC for procurement of 1000 buses and it was a single tender for supply of 1000 BS-IV or latest buses. In the pre-bid, the quantity of 1000 buses was bifurcated into 400 BS-IV buses and 600 BS-VI buses but the tender still remained one only and the bidders could have made the bid for the entire quantity of these buses of both types”.
Another irregularity that was found was that M/s TATA Motors Ltd made a bid for 600 buses only. At the same time, JBM made a bid for 1000 buses (400 BS-IV and 600 BS-VI) at a rate higher than Tata Motors. In effect, JBM became the single bidder and therefore, the tender should have been rejected and a fresh tender should have been called by the Tender Committee.
The AAP government in Delhi has hit back at the L-G, saying the decision to initiate a CBI probe was politically motivated.
AAP MLA Saurabh Bharadwaj said, “In this matter, neither a single bus was purchased nor even a rupee was paid to anybody. Then where did the corruption take place? The Arvind Kejriwal government put the tender process on hold after some inquiry was initiated against it.”
“It was decided not to go ahead with the tender process till the conclusion of the inquiry. It is still on hold for the past two years and we could not purchase even a single bus,” Bharadwaj added.
The AAP spokesperson further stated that the L-G’s actions were just a way to deflect public attention from the corruption charges levelled against him.
“L-G Saxena, who wakes up every morning and starts levelling fake and baseless corruption charges against his own Delhi government, has recommended CBI probe into the matter yesterday for the second time in a month just to deflect public attention from the corruption charges levelled against him,” Bharadwaj charged, adding that it was “unfortunate.”
Instead of coming out and saying that he is ready to face a probe, Saxena is staging a new drama every day by levelling baseless allegations against the Kejriwal dispensation, he said.
LG रोज़ कोई पुराना मामला उठाकर Delhi Govt पर हमला करते हैं जबकि LG पर ख़ुद 3 गंभीर आरोप हैं
1️⃣Notebandi में पुराने नोटों को बदलवाने
2️⃣KVIC Chairman रहते बेटी को ठेका देने
3️⃣HC Order के बाद भी कारीगरों को Cash में भुगतान करने
LG ख़ुद जांच से भाग जाते हैं
— AAP (@AamAadmiParty) September 11, 2022
Later, AAP MP Sanjay Singh hit out at the L-G, alleging that Saxena was levelling baseless allegations against the Kejriwal government as he wants commission from the contractors in award of the government works.
“You deal with the contractors directly for commission in award of work. This business of loot and corruption that you ran at KVIC is not possible in Delhi govt,” he said.
जो काले कारनामे Khadi के Chairman रहते V K Saxena ने किये, वही भ्रष्टाचार Delhi में करना चाहते हैं। उन्हें हर Tender में Commission चाहिए
LG साहब, ये काम आम आदमी पार्टी के रहते नहीं हो सकता
LG को जेल जाना पड़ेगा। जेल का खाना, खाना पड़ेगा
— Aam Aadmi Party Delhi (@AAPDelhi) September 11, 2022
BJP’s hit out at AAP
As the AAP shrugged off allegations of irregularities, the BJP stated that “each department of the AAP government is involved in corrupt activities with contracts and tenders being tailor-made to benefit the friends of Kejriwal”.
BJP’s national spokesperson Gaurav Bhatia said, “First, it was the excise policy, now there are irregularities in the purchase of buses. Giving tenders in exchange of money has become an important part of Kejriwal’s politics. Kejriwal and corruption have become synonymous.
आप सरकार की एक ही है खूबी,
पूरी तरह से भ्रष्टाचार में है डूबी। pic.twitter.com/uzNBR7M8K3
— BJP (@BJP4India) September 11, 2022
“How can you claim to be ‘hardcore honest’? People have understood you are ‘hardcore corrupt’... You have no right to remain in the chair of the chief minister,” Bhatia said.
He said Delhi Transport Minister Kailash Gahlot was made the chairman of the committee for tendering and procurement of buses by Delhi Transport Corporation (DTC) “with the intention of giving benefits to friends”.
With inputs from agencies
He appealed to the voters not to vote for the decades-old party as it was ‘never going to form the government’
AAP demands L-G's resignation after Sisodia’s name doesn’t figure in CBI’s first chargesheet on Delhi Excise Policy scam
AAP convener and Delhi chief minister Arvind Kejriwal also reacted to the CBI chargesheet which named seven people but did not name Sisodia, calling the excise policy scam case “fake” and alleging that it was nothing but an attempt by the BJP to malign and implicate his deputy
BJP's national spokesperson Gaurav Bhatia claimed the report shows that the private firm decided the terms and conditions for the construction of classrooms in collusion with the government