BJP, Opposition trade barbs in Lok Sabha as Parliament discusses Motion of Thanks on president's address
Union minister Pratap Chandra Sarangi showered praises on Modi and compared him to Swami Vivekanand, prompting Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury to retort later that he should not compare 'monk and monster'.
The BJP and Opposition members on Monday traded barbs in Lok Sabha over the Narendra Modi government
Initiating the debate on the 'Motion of Thanks' to the president's speech to Parliament, Pratap Chandra Sarangi showered praises on Modi and compared him to Swami Vivekanand
In his response, Chowdhury said the Modi government is 'compliment-addicted' and is driven by 'manipulation'
New Delhi: The BJP and Opposition members on Monday traded barbs in Lok Sabha with Union minister Pratap Chandra Sarangi asking rivals of Prime Minister Narendra Modi to respect people's mandate while the Congress attributed the saffron party's win in the general elections to Modi being a "very big salesman".
Selected by the BJP to initiate the debate on the 'Motion of Thanks' to the president's speech to Parliament, Sarangi, the debutant MP from Odisha, showered praises on Modi and compared him to Swami Vivekanand, prompting Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury to retort later that he should not compare "monk and monster".
Sarangi also raised nationalism pitch during his nearly an hour-long speech and questioned if those who do not believe in Vande Mataram and raised slogans favouring Pakistan or Afzal Guru have any right to live in India.
He also asserted that the "tukde-tukde" gang will not be tolerated.
He said that criticising Modi is like "hitting one's head against the Himalayas" and took a dig at the Opposition for allegedly seeking proof of Balakot air strike, asked if people sought proof "from their mother for addressing their fathers."
The Opposition should respect peoples' mandate for a man with humble background like Modi, he said and added the BJP's massive win in the Lok Sabha polls was also against family rule.
In his response, Chowdhury said the Modi government is "compliment-addicted" and is driven by "manipulation", as he took a swipe at Sarangi for "crossing all limits" in his praise for the prime minister and likening him to Swami Vivekanand.
"You should not compare between monk and monster," he said.
Chowdhury also used a "derogatory" term for Modi, drawing strong protests from treasury benches.
The Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla ordered expunging of the remark.
The Congress leader in Lok Sabha later clarified outside the House that he did not mean the comment and blamed it on his poor Hindi.
Chowdhury also criticised Sarangi for showering "excessive" praise for Modi, prompting Parliamentary Affairs Minister Pralhad Joshi and many other BJP leaders to refer to "India is Indira and Indira is India" comment made by the then Congress president for former prime minister Indira Gandhi.
"We have not gone to this extent," Joshi quipped, promoting Chowdhury to liken Indira Gandhi to "Ma Ganga" and Modi to a now-expunged term.
The Congress leader said the BJP returned to power as Modi was a "very big salesman" and a "better salesman" while the Congress failed to market its products in the 2019 Lok Sabha polls.
Hitting back at the BJP after Sarangi referred to alleged scams in the sale of 2G spectrum and coal block allocations, he said if there was a wrongdoing why are UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi and Congress president Rahul Gandhi not in jail.
"Why are they still in Parliament", he asked.
In his speech, Sarangi said the Congress gave India an "accidental prime minister", a reference to Manmohan Singh, and praised Modi for his strong leadership that ended "policy paralysis", "enhanced" global respect for India, targeted terrorists based in Pakistan and took welfare measures to the poor.
He said the Congress made the BJP realise the importance of strong leadership as policy paralysis was a "new norm" during the ten-year rule of the party with the "accidental prime minister" at the helm.
He said he is grateful to Narendra Modi for making a man like him, who hails from a humble background, a minister.
Taking on the Congress, Sarangi said ten years of the Congress-led UPA government was that of "misrule" and "full of corruption".
Emphasising that both Modi and his government are committed to the welfare of the poor and downtrodden, the minister said by 2022 every poor person will have a pucca house with toilet.
Listing achievements of Modi government, Sarangi said that poor women were provided gas cylinders and economically weaker sections were given reservation.
"Our goal is to make India a great nation," the BJP MP said.
Sarangi also pointed out that Modi has received many international awards.
"We will give honest government and if you will not help us then people of India will not forgive you," he told the Opposition members.
Chowdhury accused the government of "political plagiarism" syndrome , saying it claims achievements for everything and ignores the foundation laid down by the Congress.
Invoking former prime ministers Jawaharlal Nehru, Indira Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi, Chowdhury in his one-and-a-half-hour-long speech listed out the achievements under the Congress governments and accused the BJP of simply renaming 19 of the 23 schemes of the Congress.
"This government has developed a new syndrome called political plagiarism... Congress has been contributing to growth (since Independence), but one morning you suddenly say Congress has done nothing and you are doing all development work. It is nothing but travesty of truth... You are a government which can be called compliment-addicted government driven by manipulation," said Chowdhury who was the first speaker from the Opposition to initiate discussion on the Motion of Thanks.
Saugata Roy of the TMC reiterated his party's stand against use of EVMs in elections and demanded that the Election Commission revert to the use of ballot papers.
Congress leader Sonia Gandhi was seen prompting Chowdhury while he was attacking the BJP in his speech.
Both Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah were also present in the House.
Stating it was the Congress which initiated major initiatives like 'Green Revolution', 'White Revolution' and 'Technology Revolution' in the country, and increased GDP growth, Chowdhury said it was also under the Congress that host of CPSEs like ONGC, IOC, NTPC, SBI and HAL were set up.
"Congress is the soul of the nation. Congress is synonymous with India... For us, country is ahead of the party... Although we have 52 members in the House, but we will continue to fight for the common man," he said.
He said the BJP did not mention Nehrus name in the presidents address even once and that it does not show 'Sabka Sath, Sabka Vikas' attitude of the government.
Crediting Congress for a slew of government schemes and initiatives like NREGA, RTI, Right to Education and Food Security Act, Chowdhury said, "you talk about hitting back at Pakistan with missiles. These missiles were built during the Congress tenure."
Targeting the Modi government, Chowdhury said the country is reeling under drought, but the government is not worried.
He said BJP MPs did not take steps to alleviate miseries of the people as they think Modi will do everything. "They think that praising Modi is sufficient, he will help them sail through (Modi baba paar lagayenge),"he said.
Samajwadi Party leader Azam Khan attacked the BJP over its Hindutva politics, saying Muslims had a choice to go to Pakistan during partition and "our forefathers decided to stay here".
"You (BJP) never had this choice. But it hurts when we are forced to recite Vande Mataram," he said. He also termed the 'triple talaq' bill as "unacceptable".
The AIPOC is celebrating its 100th year in 2021 and to commemorate the occasion, its 82nd edition will be held in Shimla. The first conference was also held in Shimla in 1921
Centre calls all-party meet on Sunday ahead of Parliament's Winter Session, PM Modi likely to attend
On Sunday evening, Rajya Sabha Chairman M Venkaiah Naidu has called a meeting of the floor leaders of the Upper House of Parliament
Narendra Modi showed good intent with farm law repeal, now he should showcase strong, decisive leadership
In a post-truth, Orwellian world where China is seen as a democracy and India an authoritarian state, and where ‘progressive doublethink’ is a way of life, a strong, decisive government is the need of the hour in India