Sensex new high: Old-time investor is a sad man today

Why the Indian retail investor is still not smiling <br /><br /> <br /><br /> <br /><br /> <br /><br /> <br /><br /> <br /><br /> <br /><br /> <br /><br /> <br /><br />

Vivek Kaul December 21, 2014 03:50:47 IST
Sensex new high: Old-time investor is a sad man today

"So your horns are shining," he said.

"Yes," said the bull "with the BSE Sensex at an all time high and all that."

"You must be really happy today?"

"Yes. It's taken me nearly six years to get there," replied the bull. "The last time the Sensex reached these levels was in early January 2008."

"Yes, I know. It's been a tough ride."

"But why are you so sad?" asked the bull. "I don't see any champagne bottles lying around."

"You know the first time I invested in the stock market was in late 1991."

"Ah, seems like you are old timer," said the bull. "Your white hair should have told me that."

"And I made a few good gains. Got my friends and family to invest as well."

"Yes, yes. That's a good thing to do. If there is a good deal going, no harm in friends and family also benefiting a little."

"Then on April 23, 1992, it all came crashing."

"Oh, what happened?" asked the bull.

"Arre Harshad bhai's game came to an end."

"Harshad who?"

"Ah. You are a bull. How come you have never heard of him?" he asked.

Sensex new high Oldtime investor is a sad man today

With the BSE Sensex at an all time high, the bull's horn is definitely shining. Reuters

"So tell me then."

"Harshad Mehta."

"Ah. Now I remember. My father used to tell me about him. He was the Big Bull among us small bulls."

"Yes. That's what they called him when he drove around in his Lexus. He was the Amitabh Bachchan of stock brokers."

"Oh, really?" asked the bull.

"But then his luck ran out. All he had been doing was siphoning off money from the banking system and investing it into the stock market."

"And that drove up the market?"

"It sure did. The system finally caught up with him. And a huge number of cases were filed against him. He died on December 31, 2001, in a jail in Thane. At that time a decision had been made in only in one of the many cases that had been filed against him."

"You must have lost a lot of money?"

"Yes, I did. But then I told myself, only if I had got out at the right time I would have made a lot of money."

"Yes, that is the trick," said the bull.

"And then in 1994, a lot of new companies started hitting the stock market with their initial public offerings (IPOs). And my brother-in-law had become a broker by then."

"That's cool."

"And he asked me to put some money in these companies and I did."

"You must have surely made money there. IPOs are a sure shot way of making money," said the bull.

"Actually I did not. These companies simply took the money and disappeared. I guess no one ever made a proper estimate of how much money was looted. But it must have run into thousands of crores," he said.

"Oh, so you have been bitten by the stock market, twice."

"Then I took a break from the stock market and decided to go back to the good old fixed deposit."

"But fixed deposits are boring," jeered the bull.

"Oh, sure they are," he replied. "But they ensure safety of capital."

"And you never invested in the stock market after that?"

"Well I held out till 2000."

"Then what happened?"

"I saw everyone around me making money in what came to be known as K-10 stocks."

"Yes, I have heard of K-10," said the bull. "Some of those stocks are still around."

"So K-10 stocks were stocks which were a favourite with the broker Ketan Parekh."

"Yes, another Big Bull."

"These included stocks were Aftek Infosys, DSQ Software, Global Telesystems (GTL), Himachal Futuristic Communiations Ltd (HFCL), Ranbaxy Labs, SSI, Silverline, Satyam Computers, Pentamedia Graphics and Zee Telefilms."

"Some of these names are still around."

"Yes, they are. Also, around the same time the dotcom boom was also on. Hence, the price of information technology stocks was also going through the roof."

"Yes, I remember that. I was just starting my innings in the stock market then," said the bull.

"So someone told me there is this company called Infosys, you should invest in that."

"And you did?"

"Yes I did. And this time I decided to do some research."

"Yes, research is a must before investing in the stock market," said the bull, making another motherhood statement.

"The stock price had shot up from around Rs 2000 (Rs 10 paid up) in January 1999 to Rs 12,000 (Rs 5 paid up) in March 2000."

"Massive returns."

"Yes. I knew that the stock was overpriced."

"But you still bought?"

"Yes. Well I thought I was smarter than the others and would be able to find a greater fool to unload my shares on."

"And that did not happen?" asked the bull.

"No, it did not. And I was stuck with huge positions in IT stocks. In fact, I found a beautiful explanation of how big a fool I was in a book called Stocks to Riches written by stock broker Paragh Parikh. Parikh wrote "In the financial year 2000, Infosys reported revenues of Rs 882 crore.

If we were to compound this figure at 85% annually for 10 years (as some people believed the growth would continue), then in 2010, Infosys would report revenues of a staggering Rs 4,14,176 crore. At that time, assuming a market capitalisation of 100 times revenues (similar to what Infosys was quoting at its peak), it would put Infosys' value at $9.2 trillion. The GDP of the US was around the same figure!""

"Oh, freak."

"That was how stupid the Infosys trade was at that point of time."


"The system also caught up with Ketan bhai. He was also siphoning off money from banks and investing it into the stock market. So after this I decided enough is enough, and retired from the stock market. I placed all my money in fixed deposits, post office savings schemes and some of it went into real estate."

"And you lived happily ever after?" asked the bull.

"Only bulls can do that," he replied.


"Well the market started to rally again sometime in 2003. But I managed to resist for a few years. Then one day, my brother in law, who had become an insurance agent by then, came to me."

"And then?"

"He told me, ke boss, forget stock market, too much risk. You should try this new product called unit linked insurance plan (Ulip)."

"And you invested?"

"Not immediately. I resisted for a while. But finally I took the plunge in January 2008."

"Ah, not the best time to invest."


"But now with the Sensex crossing its previous all time high, your investment must be in positive territory again."

"Nah. It took me two years to figure out the Ulip structure, it was so complicated. My brother in law was paid a huge commission for selling me the Ulip. That commission was recovered from me as a premium allocation charge. Then there were other charges like policy administration charge, and what not. So my investment is still in the red.. Only insurance agents made money of Ulips."

"That's sad," said the bull.

"Yes, it is," he replied. "Hopefully, I should be able to stay away from the market from now on."

"But who are you?"

"Oh, I didn't tell you," he replied. "I am the Indian retail investor who lives in perpetual hope. Wo subah kabhi to aayegi."

(Vivek Kaul is a retail investor who has been religiously continuing with his SIPs since 2006 in the hope that he will make money one day. He tweets @kaul_vivek)

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

California skies glow orange as firefighters battle wildfires that rage across 25 miles in a day

California skies glow orange as firefighters battle wildfires that rage across 25 miles in a day

Since the middle of August, fires in California have killed eight people, destroyed more than 3,600 structures, and forced evacuations in communities near the coast, and along the Sierra Nevada

Formula 1 2020: Lewis Hamilton grabs 95th career pole in Tuscan GP qualifying as Mercedes lock front row out

Formula 1 2020: Lewis Hamilton grabs 95th career pole in Tuscan GP qualifying as Mercedes lock front row out

Bottas had been fastest in all three practice sessions, but he was unable to maintain his superiority over Hamilton in the decisive hour.

Formula 1 2020: Drivers brace for white-knuckle weekend in Tuscany as Mugello circuit readies for debut

Formula 1 2020: Drivers brace for white-knuckle weekend in Tuscany as Mugello circuit readies for debut

The spectacular Mugello circuit is normally used for MotoGP and some junior categories of single-seat car racing – but has never before hosted an F1 Grand Prix.