Rohingya deportation case: Illegal immigrants can't claim fundamental rights, not even those available to non-citizens, govt tells SC

Illegal immigrants cannot claim fundamental rights which are otherwise available even to non-citizens, the Centre on Tuesday told the Supreme Court in its fresh response to the PIL of two Rohingya refugees challenging their deportation to Myanmar.

PTI October 03, 2017 19:41:01 IST
Rohingya deportation case: Illegal immigrants can't claim fundamental rights, not even those available to non-citizens, govt tells SC

New Delhi: Illegal immigrants cannot claim fundamental rights which are otherwise available even to non-citizens, the Centre on Tuesday told the Supreme Court in its fresh response to the PIL of two Rohingya refugees challenging their deportation to Myanmar.

Rohingya deportation case Illegal immigrants cant claim fundamental rights not even those available to noncitizens govt tells SC

Representational image. Reuters

The government filed its response to the rejoinder affidavit of Rohingya immigrants Mohammad Salimullah and Mohammad Shaqir, who have filed the PIL alleging they had faced persecution in Myanmar and were forced to flee.

In the fresh surrejoinder (a plaintiff's reply to a defendant's rejoinder), the government submitted that though it was "fully conscious, aware and responsible about its obligations emanating from various international instruments", but certain views expressed by Indian representatives and the contentions, based on "declarations/resolutions/international instruments" were devoid of merits.

"As a sovereign state, India will always honour such obligations which are binding obligations. Having said that,it is reiterated that India is not a signatory to United Nation Convention of 1951 and the Protocol of 1967 issued there under.

"The said convention/protocol is, therefore, not binding upon India and no other declaration/resolution/convention/international treaty or instrument of any kind is in force which prohibits India, as a sovereign nation, to exercise its right of deporting illegal immigrants in accordance with laws of India and thereby protecting the fundamental rights of its own citizens more particularly in the interest of national security," the Centre said.

Meanwhile, the apex court on Tuesday fixed a batch of pleas on Rohingya issue for hearing on 13 October and asked the Centre and others to file documents including international conventions for its assistance.

The rejoinder affidavit of the ministry of home affairs also said there was no binding legal obligation on India with respect of non-refoulement flowing from any binding international instrument. Non-refoulement means the practice of not forcing refugees or asylum seekers to return to a country where they are liable to be subjected to persecution.

"I submit that the illegal immigrants would not get and cannot claim any of the fundamental rights which are otherwise available to non-citizens as the term "non-citizens" would necessarily mean persons, not citizens of India, are in India on a valid travel document," Mukesh Mittal, joint secretary(foreigners) with the MHA told the court.

"The framers of the Constitution of India would not have envisaged a situation where thousands and thousands of people would be flowing into this country entering illegally without any valid travel documents and start claiming fundamental rights as non-citizens," he added.

Earlier, the Centre had termed Rohingya refugees as "illegal" immigrants and said that some of them were part of a "sinister" design of Pakistan's ISI and terror groups such as the ISIS, whose presence in the country will pose a "serious" national security threat.

Updated Date:

also read

PSU banks may take hit of Rs 2,000 cr due to SC order on loan compound interest waiver
India

PSU banks may take hit of Rs 2,000 cr due to SC order on loan compound interest waiver

The apex court's judgment covers loans above Rs 2 crore, as loans less than the amount got blanket interest on interest waiver in November 2020

Myanmar protests: Civilian toll climbs past 700 as junta continues brutal crackdown on dissent
World

Myanmar protests: Civilian toll climbs past 700 as junta continues brutal crackdown on dissent

Myawaddy Bank's biggest branch in Mandalay was targeted on Sunday morning and a security guard was injured in the explosion, according to local media

Myanmar youth battle internet shutdown with Molotov, an explosive underground newsletter
World

Myanmar youth battle internet shutdown with Molotov, an explosive underground newsletter

Thirty-year-old Lynn Thant, not his real name, started the underground newsletter and gave it the edgy name Molotov to appeal to young people.