Rafale aircraft row: CAG refuses to share audit details, says any disclosure will cause 'breach of Parliament'

In its response to Pune-based activist Vihar Durve who had sought the report from CAG, the country's auditor said, 'The audit is under progress and the report is yet to be finalised.'

Press Trust of India January 15, 2019 19:41:48 IST
Rafale aircraft row: CAG refuses to share audit details, says any disclosure will cause 'breach of Parliament'
  • The CAG also refused to share its correspondence related to the audit of Rafale deal with any government department or political party

  • It also added that audit in the IAF is done by designated principal audit officer of the force

  • The reports are submitted to the national auditor for approval

New Delhi: The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has refused to disclose details about its audit in the controversial Rafale aircraft deal, saying the process is not yet complete and any disclosure at this stage will amount to breach of the Parliament's privilege, an RTI reply said.

In its response to Pune-based activist Vihar Durve who had sought the report from CAG, the country's auditor said, "The audit is under progress and the report is yet to be finalised. The information cannot be given under Section 8(1)(C) of the RTI Act as the disclosure would cause breach of Parliament".

Rafale aircraft row CAG refuses to share audit details says any disclosure will cause breach of Parliament

Representational image. Reuters

Section 8(1)(C) of the Right To Information (RTI) Act exempts information the disclosure of which would cause a breach of privilege of Parliament or the State Legislature.

The Supreme Court, in December, had dismissed pleas challenging the deal between India and France for procurement of 36 Rafale jets, saying there was no occasion to "really doubt the decision making process" warranting setting aside of the contract.

It rejected the pleas seeking lodging of an FIR and a court-monitored probe alleging irregularities in the Rs 58,000 crore deal, in which both the countries have entered into an inter-governmental agreement (IGA).

"The pricing details have, however, been shared with the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG), and the report of the CAG has been examined by the Public Accounts Committee (PAC). Only a redacted portion of the report was placed before the Parliament and is in public domain," the bench led by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi had said, relying on the sealed note submitted by the government.

After the Congress raised the issue that no such CAG report had been placed before the PAC, the government approached the court seeking changes in the judgment.

In the application, the Centre said the two sentences in paragraph 25 of the judgement appeared to have been based on the note submitted by it along with the pricing details in a sealed cover, but indicated the words used by the court lent a different meaning.

The Centre made it clear that it did not say that the CAG report was examined by PAC or a redacted portion was placed before Parliament. It clarified that the note had said the government "has already shared" the price details with the CAG, which was written in past tense and "is factually correct".

However, where it was stated by the Centre in the note that the report of the CAG "is" examined by the PAC, was a description of the procedure which is followed in the normal course, but in the judgement, 'is' was replaced with the words 'has been', according to the application.

In its response to the RTI application filed by Durve, the CAG also refused to share its correspondence related to the audit of Rafale deal with any government department or political party, claiming that such records were "confidential and held in fiduciary capacity" hence, exempted from disclosure under the RTI Act.

The CAG added that audit in the Indian Air Force (IAF) is done by designated principal audit officer of the force and the reports are submitted to the national auditor for approval.

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

SC dismisses plea seeking cancellation of remaining Rajasthan Class 10 board exams scheduled for 29, 30 June
India

SC dismisses plea seeking cancellation of remaining Rajasthan Class 10 board exams scheduled for 29, 30 June

The top court said that the petitioner has not referred to even a single instance in the deficiency of facilities or flouting of any protocol specified by the Central or state government in any examination centre, whilst conducting such examination during the COVID-19 pandemic.

School fees during lockdown: Parents from different states move Supreme Court, seek moratorium on dues
India

School fees during lockdown: Parents from different states move Supreme Court, seek moratorium on dues

Parents of the school going children who have moved the top court hail from Rajasthan, Odisha, Punjab, Gujarat, Haryana, Uttarakhand, Delhi and Maharashtra.

SC asks Centre if individual orders cancelling visas were served to foreign attendees of Tablighi Jamaat meet; matter posted for 2 July
India

SC asks Centre if individual orders cancelling visas were served to foreign attendees of Tablighi Jamaat meet; matter posted for 2 July

Thirty-four foreigners from 15 countries, who had attended the Tablighi Jamaat meet in March, approached the Supreme Court claiming they were not issued individual orders regarding blacklisting and FIRs