Jammu and Kashmir HC rejects plea to ban pellet guns, adduces unruly mobs

Rejecting a plea seeking ban on use of pellet guns in controlling street protests in Kashmir Valley, the Jammu and Kashmir High Court has cited the ground situation and observed that as long as there is violence by unruly mobs, use of force is inevitable.

PTI September 22, 2016 15:14:33 IST
Jammu and Kashmir HC rejects plea to ban pellet guns, adduces unruly mobs

Srinagar: Rejecting a plea seeking ban on use of pellet guns in controlling street protests in Kashmir Valley, the Jammu and Kashmir High Court has cited the ground situation and observed that as long as there is violence by unruly mobs, use of force is inevitable.

Jammu and Kashmir HC rejects plea to ban pellet guns adduces unruly mobs

Representational image. PTI

A bench comprising Chief Justice N Paul Vasanthakumar and Justice Ali Mohammad Magrey also declined the plea to prosecute the officers who ordered use of pellet guns or fired them even as it directed the authorities to provide adequate medical treatment to the injured by specialists in or outside the state.

"Having regard to the ground situation prevailing as of now and the fact that Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs has already constituted a Committee of Experts through its Memorandum dated 26 July, 2016 for exploring other alternative to pellet guns...."

"Before filing of the report by the Expert Committee and a decision taken at the government level, we are not inclined to prohibit the use of pellet guns in rare and extreme situations," the court said in its order in Srinagar on Wednesday.

The bench was hearing a petition filed by Kashmir High Court Bar Association seeking ban on use of pellet guns for crowd control.

The court said "it is manifest that so long as there is violence by unruly mobs, use of force is inevitable".

What kind of force has to be used at the relevant point of time or in a given situation or place, has to be decided by the persons in-charge of the place where the attack is happening, it said.

"This court in the writ jurisdiction without any finding rendered by the competent forum/ authority cannot decide as to whether the use of force in particular incident is excessive or not," the court said.

The bench also declined the plea to prosecute the officers who ordered use of pellet guns and those who actually fired them.

"Same cannot be considered in this petition as no findings on use of excessive force, violating the guidelines issued in SOP (Standard Operating Procedure), have been recorded by any fact-finding authority," it said.

Hence the persons alleging use of excessive force due to which death or injury has occurred, can very well approach the appropriate forum to establish the same and seek redressal, the bench ruled.

However, the court said the pendency of the PIL with regard to other prayers will not be a bar for the state government for paying compensation to deserving family members of the deceased or injured persons.

The court directed the concerned authorities to ensure that all the injured are extended adequate medical treatment for whatever injury they sustain and provide all possible required medical treatment to the injured by specialists.

If specialists are not available in the state, appropriate arrangement has to be made to treat the patients by inviting specialists in the state or to shift the patients to hospitals outside the state wherever specialists are available, the court said.

Updated Date:

also read

Pinarayi Vijayan says night curfew, stringent COVID curbs in Kerala will be lifted forthwith
India

Pinarayi Vijayan says night curfew, stringent COVID curbs in Kerala will be lifted forthwith

The move comes as the state on Tuesday reported 25,772 fresh COVID-19 cases.

Pakistan continues to foment 'culture of violence at home' and across its borders, says India at UN
India

Pakistan continues to foment 'culture of violence at home' and across its borders, says India at UN

India's strong response came after Islamabad's envoy to the UN raked up the issue of Jammu and Kashmir and spoke about the late pro-Pakistan leader Syed Ali Shah Geelani in his remarks to the General Assembly

Rahul treks 14 km to Vaishno Devi: A look at some of his other temple visits
India

Rahul treks 14 km to Vaishno Devi: A look at some of his other temple visits

The Congress leader has made trips to Gujarat's Akshardham temple and the Mahakaleshwar temple in Ujjain in the past