Ishrat Jahan should be given benefit of doubt, GK Pillai had said in 2013

Former Home Secretary GK Pillai, who has hit the headlines recently with his statements on the Ishrat Jahan killing, had said in 2013 that she has to be given the benefit of doubt.

hidden March 04, 2016 18:29:19 IST
Ishrat Jahan should be given benefit of doubt, GK Pillai had said in 2013

New Delhi: Former Home Secretary GK Pillai, who has hit the headlines recently with his statements on the Ishrat Jahan killing, had said in 2013 that she has to be given the benefit of doubt on the issue whether she was an LeT operative.

Ishrat Jahan should be given benefit of doubt GK Pillai had said in 2013

Ishrat Jahan. IBNLive

"I don't think there is any conclusive evidence against Ishrat Jahan. Unless any proper investigation is carried out, we will have to give her the benefit of doubt," the retired bureaucrat had said in 2013.

Pillai had recently stoked a controversy saying that the the second affidavit of the Central government in Gujarat High Court filed in 2009 contradicting the earlier affidavit's claim that Jahan was an LeT operative was drafted by the then Home Minister P Chidambaram without consulting officials.

Ishrat, Javed Shaikh alias Pranesh Pillai, Amjadali Akbarali Rana and Zeeshan Johar were killed in an alleged encounter with Gujarat Police on the outskirts of Ahmedabad on 15 June, 2004.

After Pillai's recent statement, Chidambaram owned up responsibility for the second affidavit but expressed disappointment over the retired bureaucrat distancing himself from it.

Pillai had said last week that "I would say that she knew something was wrong and an unmarried Muslim girl would not go with a married person to different places, etc. spend the night outside....perhaps she knew that something was happening. She could have been a cover."

Asked to comment on his comments in 2013 and the recent remarks, he said, "My comment in 2013 was in a particularly context. The context was not to vilify a dead person unless further investigation threw up more evidence.

"I have said even now that evidence is not conclusive about Ishrat's LeT membership. But her conduct of travelling with Javed raises questions that something was amiss."

PTI

Updated Date:

also read

Mystery 'space debris' falls from space in three Gujarat villages
India

Mystery 'space debris' falls from space in three Gujarat villages

The officials informed that the debris landed away from a house in Khambholaj while in the other two places, it had fallen in an open area. They were not sure about the kind of space debris this was but it had fallen from the sky as was informed by the villagers.

IMD advises fishermen in north Gujarat not to venture into Arabian Sea from 27 to 29 May
India

IMD advises fishermen in north Gujarat not to venture into Arabian Sea from 27 to 29 May

The India Meteorological Department has said that strong winds with speeds reaching 40 to 50 kmph are very likely to prevail along and off the north Gujarat coast from Friday to Sunday

Gujarat HC declines to interfere with civic body notice on removal of Surat madrasa
India

Gujarat HC declines to interfere with civic body notice on removal of Surat madrasa

The Waqf committee was first issued a notice by the SMC on October 1, 2021, for removal of "illegal construction" on the ground the petitioner was an "unauthorised occupant" of the land