CBI urges Delhi HC for exemption from RTI

Ironically, the information which CBI wanted to withhold on this RTI plea has been disclosed by Ministry of Personnel in a number of responses to Parliament members.

hidden February 18, 2013 15:23:35 IST
CBI urges Delhi HC for exemption from RTI

New Delhi: CBI has approached the Delhi High Court claiming protection from disclosure of information held by it on allegations of corruption under the Right to Information Act.

The CBI's move to approach the Delhi High Court came on a Central Information Commission decision allowing RTI plea of activist C J Karira who had sought information related to status of sanction for prosecution against public servants facing allegations of corruption during 2007-11.

CBI urges Delhi HC for exemption from RTI

Image for representation only. Reuters

Ironically, the information which CBI wanted to withhold on this RTI plea has been disclosed by Ministry of Personnel in a number of responses to Parliament members.

The court of Justice Rajiv Shakdher has stayed the CIC order and fixed the matter on April 3.

In 2011, the central government brought CBI which was probing several high profile corruption cases including 2G scam case, CWG case, illegal mining case, Adarsh Housing Society scam, under the schedule of organisations exempted from making disclosure under the RTI Act.

According to Section 24 (1) of the RTI Act, under which exempted organisations have been listed, "the information" (defined as any material in any form held by or under the control of a public authority) pertaining to allegations of corruption and human rights do not enjoy the cover.

In one of the cases cited by CBI itself in its plea before the High Court, the CIC had directed the DRI (an exempted organisation) to disclose information related to allegations of corruption.

A full bench of the CIC had also directed Enforcement Directorate to disclose information related to blackmoney as it was considered to be a case of alleged corruption.

In its plea before the High Court, CBI has claimed that provision of allegations of corruption is only applicable when it is against its employees and not all the information held by or under its control.

The contention of the agency, facing criticism from political parties and social activists for poor record in high profile corruption cases, has been rejected by CIC, activists and Information Commissioners.

PTI

Updated Date:

also read

New BCCI ACU chief Shabir Hussein Shekhadam Khandwawala against legalising betting in India
First Cricket News

New BCCI ACU chief Shabir Hussein Shekhadam Khandwawala against legalising betting in India

There is a school of thought that legalising betting will bring in massive revenues for the government at a time when most of it is going unchecked. But Khandwawala looks at it differently.

Former Gujarat DGP Shabir Hussein takes over from Ajit Singh as BCCI Anti-Corruption Unit chief
First Cricket News

Former Gujarat DGP Shabir Hussein takes over from Ajit Singh as BCCI Anti-Corruption Unit chief

The new ACU chief will be flying to Chennai on Wednesday. He also attended the final ODI between England and India in March to get an idea of how things work in the board.

The real business of politics: Parties are united by one ideology — maximising profit, maintaining systems of power
India

The real business of politics: Parties are united by one ideology — maximising profit, maintaining systems of power

The politicians are only the stars of the election movies in which voters are the audience and party workers, the extras. The real power, ultimately, resides with those who decide which star and which script to back: the financiers.