Aircel-Maxis deal: SC asks Marans to raise it before Special Court

The apex court said the Marans could state before the Special Court that the Aircel-Maxis case was not part of the 2G spectrum scam and therefore cannot be heard by the designated judge who has been nominated to hold prosecution of the cases exclusively arising out of the 2G scam.

hidden February 09, 2015 18:13:23 IST
Aircel-Maxis deal: SC asks Marans to raise it before Special Court

The Supreme Court today disallowed DMK's Dayanidhi Maran and his brother Kalanithi from approaching Delhi High Court against the special CBI court order summoning them as accused in Aircel-Maxis case arising
out of the probe into the 2G spectrum allocation scam.

The apex court said the Marans could state before the Special Court that the Aircel-Maxis case was not part of the 2G spectrum scam and therefore cannot be heard by the designated judge who has been nominated to hold prosecution of the cases exclusively arising out of the 2G scam.

"We make it clear that we are not giving any liberty to petitioners (Maran brothers) to approach the Delhi High Court but the special court would decide the juridictional issue raised by the petitioers," a bench comprising Justices V Gopalagowda and R Banumathi said. The bench said it was restoring the recalled order of February 6 to the extent only that their petitions were declared disposed of as withdrawn while making it clear that there was no liberty to approach the High Court.

AircelMaxis deal SC asks Marans to raise it before Special Court

Dayanidhi Maran

Hours after declining to entertain the plea of former Telecom Minister Dayanidhi Maran and his brother Kalanithi Maran in the Aircel-Maxis case and asking them to approach the High Court against the trial court order summoning them as accused, the bench had recalled its order on February 6.

The order was recalled after the CBI mentioned that the apex court judgements and orders were clear that no court, other than the top court, was entitled to hear any appeal arising out of the 2G scam cases.

However, the Chief Justice of India had then asked the bench to look the issue afresh. The bench, after hearing all the parties, passed the order with the observation "we are not inclined to pronounce judgement that whether it (Aircel-Maxis case) is 2G case or not. You have to go before the Special Court and agitate there and get an order".

"We are bound by the judgements of this court. We can neither deviate nor differ. If we differ, we have to refer it to a larger bench," the bench said. The observation came after considering CBI's submission
by its senior advocate K K Venugopal, who argued that there were series of apex court judgements since 2011 that appeals arising out of the 2G cases cannot be heard by any court other than the apex court.

PTI

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Two Dalit girls found dead in UP's Fatehpur: Kin allege rape, seek CBI probe; autopsy points to drowning
India

Two Dalit girls found dead in UP's Fatehpur: Kin allege rape, seek CBI probe; autopsy points to drowning

The girls' uncle had alleged that when he was informing the district magistrate about the incident over the phone, a police constable came to him and told him not to speak about this to anyone

Unnao custodial death: Delhi HC grants time to CBI for reply on Kuldeep Sengar's appeal against jail term
India

Unnao custodial death: Delhi HC grants time to CBI for reply on Kuldeep Sengar's appeal against jail term

On 4 March, Sengar, his brother, and five others were convicted for the death of the Unnao victim’s father in judicial custody by a trial court, which sentenced them to 10 years in prison

IMA ponzi scam: Ex-Karnataka minister R Roshan Baig arrested by CBI, remanded to 14-day judicial custody
India

IMA ponzi scam: Ex-Karnataka minister R Roshan Baig arrested by CBI, remanded to 14-day judicial custody

The multi-crore ponzi scheme run by Karnataka-based IMA group allegedly duped over one lakh people to the tune of Rs 4,000 crore, promising higher returns using "Islamic ways of investment"