Coronavirus Outbreak: What is plasma therapy? Is it the miracle cure the world has been waiting for?
ICMR has given Kerala their approval to conduct a clinical trial for plasma therapy on critically ill patients in its hospitals.
The top medical research body of India, the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR), on Thursday, has approved a clinical trial for plasma treatment for people who are infected with COVID-19 and are seriously ill. Many countries around the world have begun using plasma to treat patients infected with coronavirus and the treatment has shown some favourable results in improving patient health. Currently, there is no cure for the virus but there are many ongoing vaccine trials.
Kerala's Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute for Medical Sciences and Technology (SCTIMST) has been given the nod of approval by the ICMR to begin convalescent plasma therapy, reports PTI. SCTIMST is expected to start the trial by the end of this month after receiving approval from the Drugs Controller of India and the Ethics committee.
Five medical colleges - at Thiruvananthapuram, Alapuzha, Ernakulam, Thrissur and Kannur - have been included in the trials and Dr Anoop Kumar — Chief of Critical Care Medicine at Baby Memorial Hospital Kozhikode and an expert on COVID-19 — will do the clinical follow up. Additionally, The Print has reported that ICMR has only allowed these hospitals to conduct the therapy on patients who are critically ill.
“This (plasma therapy) will not be for mild patients, but (for) those who are on ventilators and under the clinical trial mode, before being recommended for all patients,” said Manoj Murhekar, Director of the Indian Institute of Epidemiology.
Dr Jagat Ram, Director, Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER) in Chandigarh, in an interview with India Today TV on Thursday, said that his institute, in collaboration with another coronavirus centre, will launch a clinical trial for plasma therapy as well. However, the representative of ICMR made no mention of this second trial.
The Delhi government, headed by Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal has sought and receieved the approval of the Centre to conduct plasma therapy clinical trials. It will be tested on critically ill patients as a form of compassionate testing.
“Trial of Plasma Enrichment technique will begin in the next three or four days. If successful, we can save the lives of serious COVID-19 patients,” Delhi CM said in an online media briefing.
An autonomous Delhi government hospital – the Institute of Liver and Biliary Sciences – has already received approval to conduct the trials.
Economic Times reported that a private hospital, Max Healthcare, has already used antibodies to treat two patients who were in the intensive care unit. The patients – members of the same family – requested the doctors to use this treatment quoting the provision of “Off Label Use”. The hospital, however, is still waiting on their approvals from ICMR to conduct trials.
Sassoon General Hospital in Pune has applied for approvals to begin randomised controlled trial and is in the process of getting a plasma separator. BJ Government Medical College in Pune is also seeking approval for an experimental convalescent plasma therapy trial. However, there are many obstacles that need to be jumped over before ICMR and the Drugs Controller General of India (DCGI) give them the all-clear.
What is convalescent plasma therapy?
Plasma therapy uses the antibodies found in the blood of people who have recovered from an infection (or convalesced), to treat patients who are infected.
According to The Associated Press, the body makes antibodies especially designed to target an infection. Those antibodies can stay in the blood — specifically the plasma i.e. the yellowish liquid part of blood — for years.
Plasma therapy is not a vaccine, but instead gives the infected person's body a boost to start producing its own antibodies. Theoretically, it can be used in patients whose immune system is too weak to fight the infection.
History of plasma therapy
The use of plasma to treat patients is not new and has been used successfully to treat patients infected with other Coronaviruses, namely Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS) and Severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS).
According to the World Health Organisation (WHO), Coronaviruses are a family of viruses that range from the common cold to more critical viruses like MERS and SARS. These viruses come from animals and can sometimes transmit from animals to humans, which is called a spillover event. However, these are rare cases, as a lot of different factors have to align in perfection for that to happen. In the case of COVID-19, they did.
The use of plasma therapy dates back to the 1900s, when first Nobel Prize awardee Emil von Behring developed a cure for diphtheria by injecting infected patients with antibodies taken from animals.
In 1918, when the Spanish flu became a pandemic similar to COVID-19, plasma therapy was used. It was particularly useful when a person was injected in the early days of their illness.
During the Ebola epidemic that started in 2013, plasma therapy was again used to treat patients as the development of vaccines always take time. The first vaccine was approved in the US in 2019, but it is a preventive measure. There is still no cure for the disease.
During the SARS pandemic in 2003, it spread to 26 countries and caused 8,000 deaths. In some cases, plasma from recovered patients were used to treat those who were infected. Seventeen years later, there is still no vaccine or cure for SARS.
The difference between vaccines and plasma therapy
When the human body is infected by an intruder, it makes antibodies to fight it. Antibodies are proteins produced by the body to neutralise or destroy toxins or disease-carrying organisms, and they are made specifically to fight that one type of disease. In order for a person to fight the disease and not get sick in the future, the antibodies help the body achieve immunity to the disease.There are two types of immunities - active and passive immunity.
Active immunity is long-lasting and sometimes life-long, but it takes weeks to develop. It occurs when the immune system produces antibodies for that disease either by getting infected or through the introduction of a weakened disease via a vaccine.
A vaccine is a biologically engineered medicine that trains the body to fight a disease it has not yet come into contact with. The weakened or inactive disease-causing microorganism is injected into the body, which in-turn prompts the body to create its own antibodies, thus giving a person immunity towards that disease. Vaccines are designed to prevent disease, rather than treat the disease once someone is infected.
Passive immunity is temporary, but immediate. It occurs when antibodies are given to a person rather than the body's immune system producing them on their own, for instance with plasma treatment.
What did China find?
The novel Coronavirus first emerged in China with at wet market in Wuhan, and the first case was detected in December 2019. However, it was only in January that the gravity of the spread of the virus began to set in. China saw a steep rise in the number of people who were getting infected and the death toll was increasing as well. While the country first brushed off the seriousness of the disease, it soon started taking extreme precautions to try and control the spread of the virus. A massive lockdown was enforced, with no one being allowed to leave the Hubei province at first, and then the country.
Researchers in China set about trying to first isolate the virus and then conduct preliminary studies that set the foundation for other researchers worldwide. In a couple of months, the virus had spread and become a pandemic.
Chinese researchers found that the virus can turn critical in older people — especially men — while children, who have better immune systems, are not as affected. They narrowed down the origin of the virus to the animals sold in the wet market - snakes, bats and pangolins. These researchers also started testing other, previously approved antiviral drugs to treat the infection.
The researchers also found that using the plasma from the blood of a person who had recovered from COVID-19 could help in the treatment of other infected patients. Reuters reported that their preliminary results were encouraging and the WHO had also approved of this approach, saying it was 'very valid'.
Dr Mike Ryan, head of WHO’s health emergencies program, told Reuters, “It (plasma therapy) is a very important area to pursue,” but "it has to be carefully timed and it’s not always successful.”
Other countries trying the same approach
China has now relaxed the lockdown after their cases have gone down drastically to single digits. Meanwhile, the USA has taken over. The number of cases in the US are much higher than they ever were in China.
The US has also joined the plasma therapy bandwagon and has begun clinical trials for plasma. They have also begun clinical trials for possible vaccines, but we will have to wait and watch for the results.
The New Zealand health authority took the bid for emergency custody to the High Court in Auckland in a case that has sparked local protest and underscored the potency of vaccine misinformation
The affidavit was filed in response to a plea by the parents of two girls who died due to adverse effects following Covid-19 vaccination. It said vaccines made by third parties had undergone regulatory review, and holding the state liable to provide compensation may not be legally sustainable
The violence in Guangzhou was a marked escalation from similar protests in Shanghai, Beijing and other Chinese cities over the weekend. The current wave of country wide protests in biggest wave of civil disobedience in China since Xi Jinping started his reign as president a decade ago