Cricket

ICC orders Pakistan Cricket Board to pay BCCI 60 percent of its legal cost incurred for compensation tussle

  • Press Trust of India
  • December 19th, 2018
  • 18:00:09 IST

Dubai: The ICC's Dispute Resolution Panel Wednesday ordered Pakistan to pay 60 per cent of the cost demanded by the BCCI after the world body's rejection of the PCB's compensation claim which blamed India for lack of bilateral series between the two nations.

Nearly a month after rejecting the Pakistan Cricket Board's (PCB) compensation claim against India for allegedly failing to honour a Memorandum of Understanding on bilateral cricket, the ICC announced the costs award for the two Boards.

File image of Ehsan Mani. Getty Images

File image of PCB chairman Ehsan Mani. Getty Images

"...the Panel orders the PCB to pay the BCCI sixty percent (60%) of: (a) the Claimed Costs; and (b) the administrative costs and expenses of the Panel...," the ICC committee said in its fresh judgement, which is binding.

The BCCI, on the other hand, has been asked to pay 40 per cent of the administrative costs and expenses of the DRC. The judgement did not specify the exact amount that was claimed by the Indian Board.

The PCB had demanded Rs 447 crore compensation after alleging that the BCCI didn't honour the MoU that required India to play six bilateral series between 2015 and 2023.

The BCCI, on its part, maintained that the alleged MoU was not binding and did not stand as Pakistan failed to honour a commitment to support the revenue model suggested by India for the ICC.

The ICC then constituted a three-member Dispute Resolution Committee (DRC) to look into the PCB's compensation claim. The hearing took place at the world body's headquarters here from October 1-3.

"For the BCCI, the victor in the arbitration, to be deprived of all its costs would appear to the Panel to be inappropriate, where the BCCI too had disputed the claim in good faith," the ICC panel stated.

The BCCI had demanded that the PCB "pay the full amount" of its legal costs and the costs of arbitral proceedings including any administrative fees of the ICC, and the fees of the panel, among other expenses.

The PCB, on its part, argued that BCCI's claims are no more than "incomplete summaries". However, the panel rejected the PCB's assertion that there should be no order on costs at all.

The panel observed that since it had rejected the PCB's claims for compensation, costs award had to be decided as well.

"However, for the BCCI to be granted all of its costs would also be inappropriate...," the panel noted and cited the letter that the Board had given the PCB which spoke of bilateral cricket between the two countries and which was the basis of Pakistan's claim.

The ICC committee felt that the BCCI could have made it clear to the PCB at the very outset that the letter was merely a declaration of intent and not the MoU that Pakistan perceived it to be.

"Such misapprehension - indeed these proceedings - would have been avoided if the BCCI, who proposed the letter, had - as it could so easily have done - made clear that it was only a declaration of intent," the DRC stated.

Updated Date: December 19, 2018 18:00:09 IST

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Will be available to play for Pakistan again once Misbah and Co leave, says Mohammad Amir
First Cricket News

Will be available to play for Pakistan again once Misbah and Co leave, says Mohammad Amir

Last week, Amir had also talked about a desperate need for a change in the environment of the Pakistan dressing room.

Shan Masood, Mohammad Abbas dropped as Pakistan include nine uncapped players for South Africa Tests
First Cricket News

Shan Masood, Mohammad Abbas dropped as Pakistan include nine uncapped players for South Africa Tests

The changes were forced after Pakistan lost both Tests in their tour of New Zealand where they failed in all three departments of the game.

Young Australian cricketers are still in 'primary school' compared to Indian counterparts, says Greg Chappell
First Cricket News

Young Australian cricketers are still in 'primary school' compared to Indian counterparts, says Greg Chappell

An Injury-hit India sans their star players notched up an incredible 2-1 win over Australia in the four-Test series and Chappell believes it is the robust domestic structure and efforts put in by BCCI which prepares its youngsters to take on the rigours of international cricket.