Ian Chappell calls for DRS overhaul, says 'manipulative' review system encourages dissent from cricketers

  • Press Trust of India
  • July 19th, 2020
  • 11:20:26 IST

Former Australia captain Ian Chappell has called for an overhaul of the Decision Review System, saying it is encouraging dissent from the players in its existing "manipulative" state.

In the ongoing Test series between England and West Indies, which has marked resumption of international cricket, three reviews are awarded per innings, one extra than usual.

"'The umpire is always right and you don't argue with his decision' used to be the first lesson a young cricketer was taught. This admirable exercise in discipline and self-control is now not applicable as the introduction of DRS is encouraging a form of player dissent," Chappell wrote for ESPNcricinfo.

The 76-year-old, who has scored 5345 runs in 75 Tests for Australia, cited the example of the current series in England to show how the DRS is being manipulated and devalued.

The umpire raises his finger as England's Rory Burns, center, leaves the field after being dismissed by West Indies’ Shannon Gabriel during the second day of the first cricket Test match between England and West Indies, at the Ageas Bowl in Southampton, England, Thursday, July 9, 2020. (Adrian Dennis/Pool via AP)

Richard Kettleborough was asked to overturn his leg before decision by the TV umpire after West Indies had challenged his not out call against Rory Burns in first Test. AP

"The look of disdain on the face of umpire Richard Kettleborough after three of his decisions were overturned early on day two of the first Test between England and West Indies, was ample proof of his feelings about the system at that moment. "My sympathies were with Kettleborough, one of the better umpires on the international panel. And with the return to a third review in the pandemic era, there are signs the system is being manipulated," Chappell said referring to the technology that was used for the first time in 2008.

The Indian cricket board did not have faith in the DRS for a long time before it embraced the technology.

Chappell said the system should never have allowed players to be a part of decision-making.

"There was a time when the BCCI distrusted the DRS. I'm no longer in lock-step with the BCCI on this because I still don't have much faith in the DRS...Right from the outset the DRS should have been placed in the hands of the umpires; players shouldn't be part of the decision-making process," he wrote.

"And the equipment and personnel involved in the DRS should be controlled and employed by the cricket authorities and not the television production company. The DRS - properly constituted - is an important ingredient in cricket decision-making; it's not part of the day's entertainment.

"There have already been some cynical examples of DRS use in the series between England and West Indies that epitomise how far the system has been devalued. It's time the DRS was the subject of a thorough overhaul," added Chappell.

Updated Date: July 19, 2020 11:20:26 IST

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Pakistan feel like being 'used and binned' by England over cancelled tour
First Cricket News

Pakistan feel like being 'used and binned' by England over cancelled tour

Pakistan travelled to England last year at a time when Covid-19 infection rates in Britain were among the highest in the world for a three-match Test and T20 series that saved the ECB millions in television rights deals.

BCCI chief Sourav Ganguly wants rescheduled Test to be fifth match of series, not a one-off
First Cricket News

BCCI chief Sourav Ganguly wants rescheduled Test to be fifth match of series, not a one-off

The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) has written to the ICC seeking a Dispute Resolution Committee (DRC) verdict on the fate of the cancelled match that was to be played at Old Trafford, Manchester. The ICC is yet to comment on the matter.

Manchester Test cancellation heightens uncertainty surrounding upcoming Ashes
First Cricket News

Manchester Test cancellation heightens uncertainty surrounding upcoming Ashes

The dramatic last-minute cancellation of the deciding fifth Test at Old Trafford has heightened the tension already surrounding the upcoming Ashes series.