Official Secrets, The Report comment on the current political environment through the motif of the whistleblower

Through fiction, movies about whistleblowers present the pervasive fear of surveillance, updating it for the digital age. They present commentary on the contemporary political climate of mistrust and highlight political ways of swaying public opinion, calling for politicians to listen to the truth.

The Conversation December 08, 2019 10:01:01 IST
Official Secrets, The Report comment on the current political environment through the motif of the whistleblower
  • In movies about whistleblowers, the pervasive fear of surveillance has been updated for the digital age.

  • Through fiction, they are presenting commentary on the contemporary political climate of mistrust and highlighting the ways politicians sway public opinion.

  • Movies such as these can be seen as calls to politicians: Truth Matters. If only they would listen.

By Catherine Edwards

The revelations surrounding US president Donald Trump’s telephone conversation with the president of Ukraine, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, are raising serious questions about attempts to solicit outside interference in US domestic affairs. The erupting impeachment scandal has placed whistleblowers firmly back on the international agenda.

In a scene from director Gavin Hood’s 2019 film Official Secrets, journalist Martin Bright (Matt Smith) meets a source in an underground car park. “Very Deep Throat,” he comments drily, referencing the famous source in the 1970s Watergate conspiracy that brought down then US president, Richard Nixon. His informant holds up her mobile phone: “No signal,” she replies, indicating the real reason for her choice of location.

Official Secrets The Report comment on the current political environment through the motif of the whistleblower

Official Secrets. Photo credit: Facebook @OSFilmUK.

In a single moment, the film – which is set in 2003 – both acknowledges its generic heritage and positions itself in the technological context of early 21st-century spycraft.

The pervasive fear of surveillance has been updated for the digital age.

Official Secrets is the first of two films released in the UK in autumn 2019 that reflect on the events that took place in the lead up to, and aftermath of, the 2003 Iraq War. It follows the decision of 27-year-old GCHQ translator Katharine Gun (Keira Knightley) to leak a memo that her employer received from the US National Security Agency (NSA) in January 2003.

The memo asked the British listening station for its cooperation in a US “surge” against selected members of the UN Security Council. The aim was to gather material designed to influence voting intentions and secure a second resolution (ultimately unsuccessfully) in support of the Iraq War.

The film dramatises Gun’s journey from loyal civil servant to whistleblower and court defendant, charting the personal and professional fall out of her actions as she finds herself pitted against the might of the British establishment – and its judicial wrath. In parallel, the film follows the painstaking processes of the investigative journalists (Martin Bright, Peter Beaumont and Ed Vulliamy) who broke the story.

Official Secrets offers a passionate and damning assessment of UK government collusion in a US dirty tricks campaign designed to sway international opinion in favour of the Iraq War. It champions the efforts of individuals who stand up for their moral principles, whether through whistleblowing, journalism, or legal activism.

While ostensibly commenting on these historical actions, the film also illuminates contemporary concerns about government secrecy, accountability, and factual manipulation.

In the UK, the alleged suppression of the Parliamentary Intelligence Security Committee (ISC) report into Russian covert activity recently prompted suspicions about what (if anything) the British government is hiding about external meddling.

The temporary brand switch of the Conservative Party Press Office Twitter account to “FactCheckUK” during a debate of party leaders in the run up to a December general election provoked complaints about an act of deliberate deception designed to muddy the (already murky) waters of online discourse.

By fictionalising historical attempts by the British government to manipulate the court of public opinion, Official Secrets invites parallels to be drawn with the current erosion of trust in the political elite.

Cover up

The second film released in November to chronicle historical efforts to hold officialdom to account is Scott Burns’ The Report. While also containing the near obligatory car park informant scene, The Report is an altogether darker, denser thriller. It follows US Senate assistant Dan Jones (Adam Driver) as he is assigned by the Senate Intelligence Committee to investigate the CIA’s programme of Enhanced Interrogation Techniques (EITs) during the post-9/11 War on Terror.

Official Secrets The Report comment on the current political environment through the motif of the whistleblower

The Report. Photo credit: Facebook @TheReportMovie.

Enhanced interrogation, it is rapidly made clear, is a euphemism for torture. Waterboarding, sleep deprivation and cramped confinement (false burial) were among 16 techniques designed to break the resistance of terror suspects. With mounting intensity and moral purpose, Jones meticulously pieces together the stories of each of the 119 detainees, eventually producing a 6,700-page report (reduced to a 700-page executive summary).

Interspersed with flashbacks of dehumanising violence, the film charts Jones’ increasingly obsessional pursuit of the truth. It is uncompromising in its denunciation of the CIA as perpetrators of torture, and of the US government for authorising its use and colluding in the cover up.

The criticism, however, is not restricted to the Bush-Cheney regime. Also in the firing line is the hypocrisy of the Obama presidency (represented in the film by John Hamm as the White House chief of staff) who, it is suggested, was only too happy to reap the benefits of CIA propaganda when it came to the 2012 re-election campaign.

Real-life dramas

In a similar way to Official Secrets, The Report both dramatises an historical event and offers an implicit commentary on the current political climate in the Anglo-American sphere.

By showing a recording of the actual speech given by the late John McCain on publication of the report, the film drags the recent past firmly into the present. It provides a glaring contrast between the bipartisan values that motivated the Senate investigation and the wilful disinformation that continues to emerge from the Trump administration.

In the present febrile political climate the tagline of The Report could be read as a clarion call to politicians on both sides of the pond: Truth Matters. If only they would listen.Official Secrets The Report comment on the current political environment through the motif of the whistleblower

Catherine Edwards, Doctoral Researcher, University of York

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Xiaomi and 8 other Chinese companies blacklisted by the US over alleged military links
News & Analysis

Xiaomi and 8 other Chinese companies blacklisted by the US over alleged military links

US investors will have to divest their stakes in Chinese companies on the military list by November this year.

PGA Championship 2022 pulled from Trump course, confirms PGA of America
Sports

PGA Championship 2022 pulled from Trump course, confirms PGA of America

"The PGA of America Board of Directors voted tonight to exercise the right to terminate the agreement to play the 2022 PGA Championship at Trump Bedminster," PGA of America President Jim Richardson said.

Apple, Google deplatform Parler over lack of moderation; app has been drawing Trump supporters after Twitter crackdown
News & Analysis

Apple, Google deplatform Parler over lack of moderation; app has been drawing Trump supporters after Twitter crackdown

With Trump now banned on Twitter and Facebook, Parler had been a logical choice to become his next megaphone