Mulan review round up: Disney+ new release is visually grand but lacks personality

Made on a huge budget of $200 million, Mulan is the most expensive movie helmed by Niki Caro

FP Trending September 04, 2020 11:07:46 IST
Mulan review round up: Disney+ new release is visually grand but lacks personality

It was a surprising tactic when Disney decided to pull Mulan out of its theatrical release plan (after multiple delays) and finally went for an OTT release on Disney+. Now all those with Disney+ subscription would have to pay a hefty extra amount to witness the Niki Caro directorial on the small screen. While rules and payment vary for every country, no news about the film being launched in India via the streaming service Hotstar has been released.

Made on a huge budget of $200 million, Mulan is the most expensive movie helmed by a woman filmmaker. Inkoo Kang of The Hollywood Reporter writes that while a theatrical release would have expertly hid the “anemic characterisations, uninvolving storyline and stunted performances” with the grand visuals, there remains little to feel much in the script that has been credited to four different writers.

Mulan review round up Disney new release is visually grand but lacks personality

Mulan. Image from Twitter

The story follows a young woman, Mulan (played by Liu Yifei) who dresses up like a man to become the representative of her family in a war. She does this to save her father from going into the battle when he is already wounded from an earlier war. However, aside from the martial arts training, what she needs to master is her inner ‘chi’.

The movie “owes more to Asian cinema, from Akira Kurosawa’s Ran to Zhang Yimou’s Hero than any Hollywood masterpiece, feels Peter Debruge of Variety. As if Caro wanted to make sure that the new Mulan is “the real thing, as John Woo or Chen Kaige might have made it” and separate from the cultural appropriation seen in the earlier Mulan.

Niki Caro of Whale Rider fame has retained “the essential structure” of the 1998 animated musical version with the introduction of a new shape-shifting antagonist and a new animal aide/protector, writes Joe Morgenstern for The Wall Street Journal. The original dragon Mushu, voiced famously by Eddie Murphy is non-existent here and has been replaced by a CGI phoenix “that materialises every now and then to guide [Mulan’s] way”.

But has the visual aspect of the movie successful in soaring the movie on its shoulders?

The live-action movie adaptation’s score on the review aggregator site Rotten Tomatoes displays a handsome 81 percent score collected from the input of 146 ratings.

Without the songs and the light humour of the animated version, “Caro and the screenwriters have gone for a humourless and even sombre tone, replacing all of the witty lines with portentous speeches about honour and loyalty”. Yet the movie stands somewhere in between a children’s delight and a teen drama. Nicholas Barber of BBC opined that “when the filmmakers removed her pet dragon, they took away most of her personality with it”.

Updated Date:

also read

Aditi Mittal on Women In Labour: There are three reasons why should you listen to Women in labour
Entertainment

Aditi Mittal on Women In Labour: There are three reasons why should you listen to Women in labour

In an exclusive conversation with Firstpost, Aditi Mittal and Christina McGillivray opened up on why this topic is important and how they came so far from Women in Labour season 1 to season 2 and much more.

Jerry Ceppos, distinguished editor, educator, passes away at 75
Entertainment

Jerry Ceppos, distinguished editor, educator, passes away at 75

The cause of death was sepsis brought on by a severe infection, according to an obituary approved by the family.

Actor and filmmaker Tyler Perry to receive honorary AARP award for uplifting communities
Entertainment

Actor and filmmaker Tyler Perry to receive honorary AARP award for uplifting communities

The organization announced Thursday that Perry will receive the honorary AARP Purpose Prize award during a virtual ceremony on Oct. 25.