Just Mercy movie review: Michael B Jordan, Jamie Foxx's straightforward legal drama exposes America's criminal injustice system

Just Mercy could have then been more than just a standard legal drama, but a punch in the gut to America's civil rights legacy.

Prahlad Srihari January 18, 2020 11:51:49 IST

3/5

For every nine people executed in the US, one innocent person has been exonerated — an unsettling margin of error revealed in the closing moments of Just Mercy.

Just Mercy movie review Michael B Jordan Jamie Foxxs straightforward legal drama exposes Americas criminal injustice system

Michael B Jordan in a still from Just Mercy

Similarly, for every statistic on the criminal justice system, there's an unsettling story to be told. Destin Daniel Cretton's film tells one which reminds us of the human toll when an imperfect justice system makes a potentially fatal error in judgement.

In 1987, Bryan Stevenson (Michael B Jordan), an idealistic young Harvard graduate, moves to Alabama to defend Walter McMillian (Jamie Foxx), a black man wrongfully imprisoned and sentenced to death row for the murder of a white teenage girl. With the help of a capable right hand in Eva Ansley (Brie Larson), he works to exonerate McMillian, but to do that, he must prepare himself for the legal and political minefield that is — the anything but sweet home — Alabama.

Just Mercy movie review Michael B Jordan Jamie Foxxs straightforward legal drama exposes Americas criminal injustice system

Jamie Foxx and Michael B Jordan in a still from Just Mercy

Like To Kill a MockingbirdJust Mercy offers a typically grim portrait of the American justice system. Its notable parallels to the Harper Lee novel — from the Alabama setting to the racist white community to the wrongful conviction of a black man — only show how little has changed since the 1930s to 1980s to even now.

Botched investigations and manipulated evidence are not exactly a thing of the past, and black men continue to endure abuse at the hands of law enforcement (through harassment, coercion or police brutality). But Cretton's direction lacks the same level of compassion Barry Jenkins brought to If Beale Street Could Talk, or the same level of outrage Ava DuVernay brought to When They See Us. So, it fails to rise above a conventional courtroom drama. It simply fits the pieces together to reveal an obvious truth about the miscarriage of justice.

Stevenson, who wrote the memoir upon which this film is based, even went on to establish the Equal Justice Initiative to provide legal representation to wrongfully convicted criminals like McMillian. But the film fails to give us a true representation of who Stevenson is, what drives him besides his job and what his internal conflicts are — at least not in a way that resonates with viewers. So, Jordan is left to flesh out the character based on limited context. Even Larson has little to work with, loitering around in the periphery.

Just Mercy movie review Michael B Jordan Jamie Foxxs straightforward legal drama exposes Americas criminal injustice system

Michael B Jordan and Brie Larson in a still from Just Mercy

Foxx enthrals as a death row convict who cannot help but accept his fate before a young man helps him find hope within hopelessness, and heart within heartbreak. McMillian is convicted by an all-white jury based on the coerced testimony of a white criminal despite his black neighbours and family providing him an airtight alibi. Having grown up in a world of such racial injustices, he is expectedly cynical when Stevenson attempts to have his case reviewed but the young lawyer helps him regain some faith in the justice system.

Rob Morgan's supporting role as McMillian's fellow death row inmate, Herbert Richardson, provides the film another painfully emotional undertone. Richardson was a Vietnam War veteran suffering from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, who never got the emotional support he needed on his return home from war. Unlike McMillian, he is guilty of his crime. But it still doesn't make his execution any less horrifying, as images of Richardson on the electric chair are intercut with Stevenson's face, as the former takes his last breath before being electrocuted to death. This not only sets up the stakes for what could be in store for McMillian but also makes you question a flawed justice system which can make mistakes it cannot rectify — a system that denounces murder and sanctions murder at the same time. It also brings to light how easily the country abandons those who fought so courageously to protect it, and promote its "democratic" agenda.

Just Mercy movie review Michael B Jordan Jamie Foxxs straightforward legal drama exposes Americas criminal injustice system

Jamie Foxx in a still from Just Mercy

Just Mercy serves as a reminder that life is never as simple as black and white, or innocent and guilty. Only you wish Cretton gave equal emphasis to style and structure as subtext, like he did with his phenomenal second feature, Short Term 12Just Mercy could have then been more than just a standard legal drama, but a punch in the gut to America's civil rights legacy.

Rating: ***

undefined

Updated Date:

Subscribe to Moneycontrol Pro at ₹499 for the first year. Use code PRO499. Limited period offer. *T&C apply

also read

Pitta Kathalu movie review: Netflix’s Telugu anthology is partially engaging despite being equally real and ambitious
Entertainment

Pitta Kathalu movie review: Netflix’s Telugu anthology is partially engaging despite being equally real and ambitious

Directed by Nag Ashwin, Tharun Bhascker, Nandini Reddy, and Sankalp Reddy, Pitta Kathalu delves into the lives of four women and how their decisions in dire circumstances change their lives.

New Spider-Man movie titled No Way Home, reveal Tom Holland, Zendaya and Jacob Batalon
Entertainment

New Spider-Man movie titled No Way Home, reveal Tom Holland, Zendaya and Jacob Batalon

Marvel revealed the official title of the new Spider Man movie a day after Tom Holland, Zendaya and Jacob Balatan teased mock titles of their film

Tuesdays & Fridays movie review: Anmol Dhillon, Jhataleka Malhotra's film is an Imtiaz Ali romance sans personality
Entertainment

Tuesdays & Fridays movie review: Anmol Dhillon, Jhataleka Malhotra's film is an Imtiaz Ali romance sans personality

Obviously modelled on Friends with Benefits and No Strings Attached, Tuesdays & Fridays is too besotted with the idea of delivering a standard Bollywood romance to ever really say something worthy of its own.