If Phillauri is a copy of Tim Burton's Corpse Bride, it's a copy of Imtiaz Ali's Love Aaj Kal too

Both Phillauri and Love Aaj Kal have a sepia-tinted flashback, with turbaned heroes (Saif and Diljit). Does that make it a copy of Imtiaz's film too?

FP Staff February 07, 2017 13:13:29 IST
If Phillauri is a copy of Tim Burton's Corpse Bride, it's a copy of Imtiaz Ali's Love Aaj Kal too

On 6 February, during a Facebook live, Anushka Sharma released the trailer of her upcoming film Phillauri, which also stars Diljit Dosanjh and Suraj Sharma.

In the film, she plays a friendly ghost who gets stuck in a tree due to some unfinished business from a past life. Suraj Sharma, who is maanglik, gets married to the tree, and therefore Anushka, and we are then told about her past, as a village belle in Phillaur, Punjab, who has a lover in Diljit Dosanjh. Diljit is a singer, and vows to travel the world to find his voice and prove himself, before returning to his love. She waits for him endlessly, ever since.

Meanwhile, Tim Burton and Mike Johnson's animated film Corpse Bride is about a man who was due to get married to girl he had never met before, but ends up fleeing the wedding and marrying a corpse bride instead. Because it's animated, the film celebrates the bride's 'deathly' looks (pun intended), and like a typical Tim Burton film, the tone is dark and comical as the same time.

Since the trailer of Phillauri released, there has been some news of the two films being similar.

If Phillauri is a copy of Tim Burtons Corpse Bride its a copy of Imtiaz Alis Love Aaj Kal too

Anushka Sharma in Phillauri, a still from the Corpse Bride. Images from Youtube.

The only thing common between the two films is that there exists, in both, a dead bride. In fact in Corpse Bride, she's dead, therefore she's closer to a zombie. Whereas in Phillauri, Anushka Sharma plays a friendly ghost who can't pass on due to a remaining desire to meet her long lost lover.

If Phillauri is being accused of plagiarising from Corpse Bride, it should also be accused of copying from Imtiaz Ali's Love Aaj Kal. Both films have two time zones — one contemporary, one in yesteryear India. Both flashbacks are treated with a sepia-tint to give it an old-world charm. Both protagonists of the flashback are turbaned: Saif in Love Aaj Kal and Diljit in Phillauri.

Doesn't make sense, right? Neither does the comparison between Phillauri and Corpse Bride, based on the premise that both have dead female leads.

It's like saying Kaabil and Daredevil are the same story because both have visually impaired leading men. Or that Neal n Nikki and Befikre should be the same because they both deal with the concept of two supposedly "wild" people unwilling to "settle down".

Ever heard of something called a plot, guys? It's pretty crucial to a film.

If Phillauri is a copy of Tim Burtons Corpse Bride its a copy of Imtiaz Alis Love Aaj Kal too

Updated Date:

also read

Bhoot Police to release a week early on 10 September on Disney+ Hotstar Multiplex
Entertainment

Bhoot Police to release a week early on 10 September on Disney+ Hotstar Multiplex

Bhoot Police stars Saif Ali Khan, Arjun Kapoor, Jacqueline Fernandez and Yami Gautam in pivotal roles

Mrunal Thakur cast opposite Aditya Roy Kapur in Thadam Hindi remake
Entertainment

Mrunal Thakur cast opposite Aditya Roy Kapur in Thadam Hindi remake

Mrunal Thakur will play a cop in Thadam, the Hindi remake of the Tamil film of the same name.

Bombay HC seeks Salman Khan's reply on Kamaal R Khan's plea in restrain order
Entertainment

Bombay HC seeks Salman Khan's reply on Kamaal R Khan's plea in restrain order

Kamaal Khan in his plea said a film viewer cannot be prohibited from making comments about a film or its characters.