Black Beauty, streaming on Disney+ Hotstar, loses the novel’s sincerity by diluting Anna Sewell’s animal welfare plea

In Disney+ Hotstar's Black Beauty, the novel’s mustang spirit diminishes into a ho-hum horse movie.

The New York Times November 28, 2020 10:55:30 IST
Black Beauty, streaming on Disney+ Hotstar, loses the novel’s sincerity by diluting Anna Sewell’s animal welfare plea

Still from Black Beauty. Image from Twitter

Written in 1877, Anna Sewell’s classic children’s novel Black Beauty warned against the abuse of horses. The pristine adaptation streaming on Disney+ Hotstar is a melodrama in need of rougher edges.

Directed by Ashley Avis (a former competitive equestrian), the movie is set in the present-day US, and features two female protagonists — the fiery mustang Black Beauty (voiced by Kate Winslet) and the recently orphaned Jo (Mackenzie Foy), now living with her Uncle John (Iain Glen), training horses at Birtwick Stables.

Angry at the world, Jo softens after meeting Beauty, a kindred spirit without a family too. On the sun-kissed pastures of the ranch, the girl and horse heal each other, until a fire destroys the stables at Birtwick. Struggling financially, John leases Beauty as a show horse to a wealthy equestrian family, the Winthrops, for their spoiled tween daughter Georgina (Fern Deacon).

Jo despises Georgina’s abusiveness toward Beauty — the brat kicks holes into the horse — yet Jo still falls for Georgina’s dreamy older brother, George (Calam Lynch). Ultimately, Birtwick sells Beauty out from under Jo. Beauty, now forced to work for new owners, endures hardships — She performs grueling rescues of lost hikers and later pulls carriages through Central Park.

Though Winslet is the marquee name on the cast list, Black Beauty materialises not as the horse’s story, but Jo’s.

Unfortunately, even that character’s grief is underwritten as she pines for a daydream teen romance and a reunion with her steadfast horse, rather than ever revisiting her parents’ death.

Avis loses the novel’s sincerity by watering down Sewell’s animal welfare plea. In this update, the humans are not as villainous. Beauty is not as prominent. And the novel’s mustang spirit diminishes into a ho-hum horse movie.

Black Beauty is streaming on Disney+ Hotstar.

Robert Daniels c.2020 The New York Times Company

Updated Date:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Tribhanga director Renuka Shahane, actors Kajol, Tanvi Azmi discuss mother-daughter dynamic in Netflix film
Entertainment

Tribhanga director Renuka Shahane, actors Kajol, Tanvi Azmi discuss mother-daughter dynamic in Netflix film

Tribhanga is the kind of film that'll probably sensitise children towards their mothers, so that they don't expect their mothers to be superhumans all the time.

Cherry teaser — After Avengers: Endgame, Tom Holland and Russo Brothers team up for crime thriller
Entertainment

Cherry teaser — After Avengers: Endgame, Tom Holland and Russo Brothers team up for crime thriller

Cherry will premiere on 12 March on Apple TV, after its release in US theatres on 26 February.

Fran Lebowitz, Martin Scorsese on how Netflix documentary Pretend It's A City tries capturing a long-forgotten NYC
Entertainment

Fran Lebowitz, Martin Scorsese on how Netflix documentary Pretend It's A City tries capturing a long-forgotten NYC

Fran Lebowitz and Martin Scorsese discuss Netflix documentary Pretend It's A City, old friendships, and braving the pandemic