1917 review round-up: Sam Mendes' war film is a 'visual knockout' with 'immersive' storytelling technique
Director Sam Mendes is returning to the war genre, with World War I drama 1917, 14 years after he helmed Jarhead (2005). Ahead of the debut of 1917 in theaters, critics are praising the technique to unfold the entire film as a single-shot, a move which appears to have paid off, as per early reviews.
The film follows two British soldiers (George McKay and Dean-Charles Chapman) in World War I, who must cross enemy lines to deliver a message which will prevent over a thousand men from walking into a deadly trap. The rest of the all-star British cast includes Benedict Cumberbatch, Richard Madden, Mark Strong, Andrew Scott, and Colin Firth.
Read what critics have to say about 1917
Peter Bradshaw of The Guardian calls Mendes's 1917 an ambitious and unshakable world war drama. He praise cinematographer Roger Deakins' efforts on presenting the film as a one-continuous shot, and writes, "The single-take technique fascinatingly creates a kind of theatrical effect: the spectacle of two people moving through an unbroken space. It is immersive, yes, but that dangerously overused word does not quite convey the paradoxical alienation that is being created: the distance, the pure strangeness. The two men’s experiences are bizarre and shocking, but a poignant and then tragic sympathy is finally dredged up from the mud of their ordeal."
Echoing similar sentiments, Scott Mendelson of Forbes notes, "Sam Mendes’ 1917 is indeed one of the best movies of the year, if not THE best. That’s a conversation for another day, but the single-take World War I action drama, concerning two grunts attempting to race across enemy lines to deliver crucial, life-saving intelligence to allies readying to wage war, is a genuine marvel of movie magic. With one brief, and entirely fair, exception, this entire 110-minute picture unfolds as a single long take as the camera swoops in and out, dives here and there and essentially creates the illusion of a real-time war flick for its duration." Further adding the film is a 'visual miracle,' Mendelson says, "It’s everything it promises to be, visually, narratively and emotionally, operating both as a technical blow-out, and just a damn great movie."
Todd McCarthy of The Hollywood Reporter calls the film a 'visual knockout,' and says, "Despite the vast complexity of the storytelling technique, the tale itself, written by Mendes and Krysty Wilson-Cairns (the latter known for writing nine episodes of Penny Dreadful), is very simple, and satisfyingly so, hinging on the single matter of whether or not an otherwise inevitable slaughter will be avoided. And it all comes predictably wrapped in the inevitable humanistic lament about the tragic waste, the millions of lives lost, the needless destruction and misuse of creative and industrial initiative." The critic concludes with, "From now on, when the discussion turns to great works of cinematography and camera operating, 1917 will always have to be high on the list."
Kate Erbland of IndieWire says, "Though 1917 is so beholden to its narrative framework, Mendes has also assembled a range of actors who add emotional depth and physical daring to a demanding idea. Chapman, likely best known to most audiences as the ill-fated young King Tommen from Game of Thrones (yes, that’s really him), serves as the film’s heart, eager to push through a seemingly impossible mission in the hopes of saving one of the few good things left in his life (his beloved brother, played in a late cameo by fellow Thrones star Richard Madden).
Check out some of the reactions here
Aaannnndddd that's your frontrunner!
'1917' is the best war film since SAVING PRIVATE RYAN. The cinematography of the year. The cinematography of the decade. Thomas Newman's orchestral masterpiece. Sam Mendes gift to cinema...and his family. Every ounce is powerful.#1917Movie pic.twitter.com/EiwCTthAX3
— Clayton Davis (@AwardsCircuit) November 23, 2019
#1917 is a tremendous piece of filmmaking. Bold in its storytelling, masterful in its execution- it's thrilling & emotional & I could not take my eyes off the screen from the second it began to the second it ended. The very definition of a film you MUST see on the big screen. Wow pic.twitter.com/KNO7Rp92TG — Erik Davis (@ErikDavis) November 23, 2019
1917 is quite a thing. Always intense, often horrific (at times it feels like watching an actual horror movie). I was skeptical of the “one continuous shot” aspect — worried it would get too cute with it — but it really works for this story, putting us right there in this hell — Mike Ryan (@mikeryan) November 23, 2019
1917: The most successful example of a film presented entirely as one long take (with whatever invisible editing cheats make that possible) since... ROPE? Emotionally immersive in a way the same techniques in GRAVITY and BIRDMAN never were for me. — Christian Blauvelt (@ctblauvelt) November 23, 2019
1917 is slated to release in India on 10 January, 2020.
Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.
Updated Date: Nov 26, 2019 12:46:28 IST