Government likely to overshoot budget deficit target as tax collections fall short

New Delhi: India’s government is likely to overshoot the budget deficit target previously set for the current fiscal year, three officials have warned, as a slowing economy creates a big shortfall in tax collections and prompts new stimulus plans. New Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman presents her first budget on 5 July, for the fiscal year ending March 2020. It is also the first budget of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s second term after his government was returned in a landslide election win last month. [caption id=“attachment_5284051” align=“alignleft” width=“380”] File image of finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman. PTI[/caption] Since becoming prime minister in 2014, Modi succeeded in improving public finances, trimming the fiscal deficit to 3.4 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) from 4.5 percent in 2013/14, mostly through subsidies cuts and fuel taxes. He is now, however, under pressure to loosen the purse strings to follow through on election promises such as increased spending on roads and housing and tax cuts for companies and individuals. “There is no other option but to defer the fiscal consolidation target as boosting economic growth and reviving private investment is our top priority,” a senior finance ministry official involved in the budget discussions, told Reuters. Such a decision would ultimately be made by the prime minister’s office after consultation with advisers, he said. That may well mean raising the fiscal deficit target to as much as 3.6 percent of GDP from an already upwardly revised target of 3.4 percent, set in February’s interim budget, he said. The original goal, set in February 2018, had been 3.3 percent. Slipping fiscal discipline would hurt the “credibility” of the budget and in turn hit investment, the bond market and the rupee, analysts say. “If the (fiscal) target does slip by 10 or 20 bps it will be seen as a setback,” said A. Prasanna, chief economist at ICICI Securities Primary Dealership in Mumbai. He said bond markets are particularly vulnerable given they still assume the government will maintain the deficit target from February’s interim budget due to a higher expected dividend from the central bank’s market investments. Difficult circumstances Officials said the main factor behind the expected slippage is a big shortfall in net tax collections that could exceed 1 trillion rupees ($14.36 billion) or about 6 percent of the initial target set in February’s interim budget. That puts the government in a particularly difficult place given recent signs of economic weakness, which has put political pressure on Modi to inject rapid fiscal stimulus. Such measures would include increased infrastructure spending and tax incentives to corporate and individual taxpayers to boost private investments and consumer demand, the officials said. Last Saturday, Modi met state chief ministers and advisers to discuss possible stimulus and ways to grow GDP to $5 trillion by 2024, from about $2.7 trillion in the March quarter. A 3.6 percent deficit target would free up about 420 billion rupees ($6.03 billion) to cut tax rates or offer new investment sweeteners, another official said. A finance ministry spokesman declined to comment for this story. In pre-budget consultations, economists, government advisers, think-tanks and officials have suggested “sector specific-packages” for small businesses, food processing, electric vehicles, exporters, the tourism industry, farmers and the rural sector, rather than general tax cuts, the first official said. In the last fiscal year, tax revenue slumped more than 11 percent, forcing the government to cut spending by more than 1.45 trillion rupees in the current fiscal year to meet the 3.4 percent of GDP deficit target, said an official in the budget division. Providing a possible boost to overall revenues in the current fiscal year is an increase in the central bank dividend to 1 trillion rupees from 690 billion rupees while the 900 billion rupee in privatisation receipts could be revised upwards slightly, one of the officials said. However, the bigger risk now is that a prolonged slowdown in private investment and consumer demand, as seen in a 20 percent fall in May auto sales, could erode tax collections even further. These problems could be compounded if a weak monsoon season, with rainfall already well behind schedule, adds to household sector pain. Limited scope for stimulus Business groups have urged the government to consider cutting the corporate tax rate and introducing incentives to boost new investments. They also complain banks have only cut lending rates 10-15 basis points despite the central bank reducing its benchmark rate by 75 basis points this year. Given these constraints, there may be a focus on measures that help free up financing to parts of the economy that need it most, particularly small businesses, which account for one-third of GDP. Bank credit to small businesses grew less than 3 percent in the year to March compared with over 8 percent for big firms and 17.8 percent for services like transport and trade. One of the government advisers said there are plans for an additional 300 billion rupees in capital injections to help state banks clean up an estimated $150 billion in bad loans, which would in turn help banks more easily lend. “We believe the fiscal channel in India is more direct and quicker and the Indian financial system is in need of some serious repair,” Soumya Kanti Ghosh, chief economist at country’s largest bank, State Bank of India said in a note last week. Follow full coverage of Union Budget 2019-20 here