Supreme Court order on NPAs: Power firms body heaves a sigh of relief, says ruling will give flexibility to restructure debt
The apex court quashed the RBI circular of 12 February, 2018, that made it mandatory for banks to recognize even a one-day default by the borrowers
The circular had outlined impractical conditions and timelines for resolution, APP director general Ashok Khurana said
The ruling provides much-needed relief to power companies like RattanIndia, GMR, GVK, IL&FS and Coastal Energen among others
RBI's circular led 34 power producers to drag the regulator first to the Allahabad High Court, which asked RBI to offer some respite
Mumbai: Welcoming the Supreme Court ruling quashing the RBI circular on the resolution of stressed assets, the Association of Power Producers Tuesday said it will give some breather and flexibility to restructure their debt.
The apex court quashed the RBI circular of 12 February, 2018, that made it mandatory for banks to recognize even a one-day default by the borrowers and resolve the problem in 180 days failing which such accounts must be referred to NCLTs for resolution for a large account of Rs 2,000 crore and above.
"The circular had outlined impractical conditions and timelines for resolution and also had an inbuilt bias against the existing owners of stressed projects," APP director- general Ashok Khurana said in a statement.
He further said with the order, stressed power companies and the lenders will have some breathing space as well as flexibility to restructure debts in a manner that
ensures continuity and value maximization for lenders as well as for borrowers.
This also provides the much-needed relief to power companies like RattanIndia, GMR, GVK, IL&FS and Coastal Energen among others which had been taken to NCLTs under the RBI circular, he said.
The order, handed out by a bench headed by justice RF Nariman said, "we declare the RBI circular ultra vires." The details of the order are awaited.
The RBI's circular led 34 power producers to drag the regulator first to the Allahabad High Court, which asked RBI to offer some respite, but the RBI did not budge and challenged it in the Supreme Court last year.
Domestic rating agency Icra had estimated the total debt impacted due to the February 12 circular at around Rs 3.8 lakh crore across 70 large borrowers, of which Rs 2 lakh crore across 34 borrowers were in the power sector.
The agency had also said 92 percent of this debt were classified as NPAs by banks as of March 2018 and also made provisions of over 25-40 percent on these accounts.
The association, through multiple representations to RBI and other authorities, had highlighted how the impugned circular did not take into account genuine difficulties faced by the developers and the underlying causes of stress.
Khurana said APP had also highlighted the circular would not help either the developers or the lenders or the sector at large, and instead it would lead to significant
erosion of value as the assets were stressed due to factors which would be faced even by new promoters, in case of change in ownership as fallout of the impugned circular.
"The verdict along with recent CCEA and union power and commerce ministries' notifications implementing the recommendations of the empowered committee will provide the
much- needed respite to all the affected parties and alleviate their stress," Khurana said.
Meanwhile, reacting to the apex court order, JSW group CFO Seshagiri Rao said the order is not life changer for defaulters or banks.
"The judgement is not going to make much of a difference as the court has only questioned the RBI's powers to pass such general directions as the regulator still
continues to have the powers to direct banks to take the companies to IBC in specific cases, which has not been reversed," Rao told PTI.
The court also has not asked banks to ignore a default, he said, and pointed out that if any bank or financial creditor can still take a company to IBC.
"The circular says if there is one-day default then from that day the banks have to find a resolution within 180 days failing which they have to refer it to IBC. I, therefore, don't think this order is not a life changer," Rao added.
The colonial-era sedition law has been invoked against the likes of author Arundhati Roy, student leaders Kanhaiya Kumar, Umar Khalid, and cartoonist Aseem Trivedi among others
In its significant order on the law that has been under intense public scrutiny, a bench headed by Chief Justice NV Ramana said there was a need to balance the interest of civil liberties and interests of citizens with that of the State
UIDAI had earlier suggested that the Aadhaar card could be issued to sex workers without insisting on proof of identity, subject to their producing a certificate issued by a gazetted Officer of NACO or a gazetted officer of health department