SBI Q4 result is a silver lining for state-run banks, but it doesn’t mean all is well

State Bank of India (SBI) has once again proved to be an outlier in the crisis-ridden public sector banking space. In the March quarter the bank has done well on almost every key financial parameters. The net profit more than doubled to Rs 2,814.82 crore from Rs 1,263.81 crore a year ago, net interest income rose 17.3 percent to Rs 18,071 crore while total provisions declined 11 percent to Rs 11,740 crore from Rs 13,174 crore in the year-ago period. More importantly, the gross non-performing assets (GNPA) has shown improvement on a quarter on quarter basis.

 SBI Q4 result is a silver lining for state-run banks, but it doesn’t mean all is well


In the March quarter, the figure fell to 6.90 percent from 7.23 percent in the December quarter and 7.14 percent in the quarter before that. A steady improvement in the NPA figures is commendable at a time when majority of the state-run banks are neck-deep in bad loans. At the end of March, there are currently fourteen state-run banks who have GNPAs above 10 percent. The top NPA-cases in the chart are Indian Overseas Bank (IoB), which has 22.39 percent GNPAs, IDBI bank with 21.25 percent, Central Bank and UCO Bank (both with above 17 percent GNPAs).

In the case of IoB, the bank has posted seven consecutive quarters of loss while IDBI Bank has been posting two successive quarters of loss. As a point of comparison, the accumulated losses of IoB in the seven quarters is at Rs 6,433 crore, not far from its current market capitalisation of Rs 6,800 crore. On account of IDBI Bank's dangerous levels of NPAs and negative return on assets (RoAs), the Reserve Bank of India, early this month, had initiated a prompt corrective action" (PCA).

SBI Q4-FY financials - May 19, 2017

Compared with state-run banks, private sector banks have fared better. Except J&K Bank, no other bank has GNPAs in double digits. But that doesn’t mean everything is alright with the private sector banks. ICICI Bank, one of the largest private lenders in the country, has seen its bad loan levels inching up over the last few quarters. At the end of March, its GNPAs stood at 7.89 percent of its loans, compared with 7.2 percent in the December quarter and 6.82 percent in the quarter prior to that. But, except for a few cases, private sector banks are relatively in a better position. An excellent case study for the Modi-government to find out what is wrong with the sarkari banks that private lenders have cracked to their advantage. Right now, the bad loan scenario in the banking sector can be termed nothing short of a crisis situation with at least 10 percent of the total loans given by banks in the stressed category. This is, however, only a conservative estimate that is taken into account.

PSB's gross non-performing assets (% of net advances)
Bank Q4-FY17 Q3-FY17 Q2-FY17 Q1-FY17 Q4-FY16
I O B 22.39 22.42 21.77 20.48 17.40
IDBI Bank 21.25 15.16 13.05 11.92 10.98
Central Bank 17.81 14.14 13.70 13.52 11.95
UCO Bank 17.12 17.18 16.51 17.19 15.43
Bank of Maharashtra 16.93 15.08 14.08 12.64 9.34
Dena Bank 16.27 14.79 13.79 11.88 9.98
United Bank 15.53 15.98 16.26 14.29 13.26
Oriental Bank 13.73 13.80 12.36 11.45 9.57
Allahabad Bank 13.09 12.51 12.28 12.33 9.76
Punjab National Bank 12.53 13.70 13.63 13.75 12.90
Andhra Bank 12.25 11.88 11.49 10.30 8.39
Union Bank 11.17 11.70 10.73 10.16 8.70
Bank of Baroda 10.46 11.40 11.35 11.15 9.99
Punjab & Sind Bank 10.45 9.40 8.63 7.23 6.48
Canara Bank 9.63 9.97 9.81 9.71 9.40
Syndicate Bank 8.50 8.69 7.72 7.53 6.70
Indian Bank 7.47 7.69 7.28 6.97 6.66
State Bank of India 6.90 7.23 7.14 6.94 6.50
Vijaya Bank 6.59 6.98 7.07 7.31 6.64
Source: CapitalinePlus

After making several efforts to crack the NPA problem such as 5:25 scheme, strategic debt restructuring (SDR) and, the scheme for sustainable structuring of stressed asset (S4A), the RBI and the government has now initiated their last ditch efforts. The recent government ordinance to give greater powers to the RBI to directly involve in the NPA battle might not yield great results (read an earlier piece here) since the permanent solution lies in offering the much-needed operational autonomy to the state-run banks by privatising them and also infusing them with private capital available.

This remains a promise so far, though the government kept assuring that it wouldn’t involve itself in the operations of state-run banks. Once the current round of bad loan clean-up is over, these banks will require large amount of capital to fill the fund gap. Since the fundamental reasons that lead to bad loan build-up do not change, after a while, NPAs will yet again start piling up. A fiscally constrained government may not be in a position to keep feeding these banks. It is even more critical now for the Modi-government to give a serious thought to give up control from the public sector banks and let market competition decide the winners and losers.

(Data contribution by Kishor Kadam)

Updated Date: May 19, 2017 17:56:51 IST