When the rupee crossed Rs 73 against the dollar, it was widely expected that it would go past 74 and then 75. Some of the experts spoke of Rs 80/$, while the traditionalist still stuck to 69-70 as a fair value. Now that the rupee has started retreating from the lows, it has come back past Rs 73/$, and then Rs 72/$ and Rs 71/$. Getting back to the sixties does not look odd as everything has changed, not just in India but globally.
It was always argued that two sets of factors affected the rupee. The fundamentals would keep the rupee within the 70-mark while the external factors were driving the rupee towards new lows, i.e. towards the 75-mark almost continuously for a few months.
Let us see what has happened since 4 November which was the turning point for us as it was the critical date when the sanctions on Iran would be fully implemented. This meant that India and other countries which drew oil from Iran would have to look elsewhere as the embargo set in. It also would have meant two things. The overall supply of oil to the global economy would come down as Iran supplied something like 4 million barrels a day. Second, the price at which we got oil from Iran tended to be lower which meant there would be an additional cost now.
With a six months’ timeline now being given, oil economics changed suddenly. Before the deadline, Saudi Arabia had assured the world that the OPEC would work towards ensuring the gap created by Iran would be filled up.
With the ban not being invoked in general, oversupply has increased and with US shale production also increasing, oversupply rules the market. To the extent that the oil-producing nations are now talking of actually cutting back output to steady prices as Brent has come down from a high of $86 to less than $65 in a month’s time. A decision will be taken on 6 December.
As oil prices came down, the rupee strengthened. The other two external factors highlighted were: Federal Reserve increasing interest rates and the trade war between USA and China which is still on, have not evidently had much influence on the rupee relative to the oil factor. In fact, most of the global currencies have taken a U-turn against the dollar and started moving upwards.
The other aspect relates to the fundamentals. As the oil economics improved in spirit, i.e. prices came down; the forex outflows steadied on account of imports moderating in value terms.
Meanwhile, the government too had announced measures to curb the growth of imports, especially consumer electronics, which at the margin has helped. With the rupee becoming stronger, the case of Reserve Bank of India (RBI) selling dollars which meant depletion of forex reserves, too, has stopped and market believes now that the central bank may become a buyer soon. Add to this the fact that the foreign portfolio investor (FPI) has turned positive and the fundamentals look healthier than before.
FPIs tend to move with the currency. With the rupee falling, there were reasons to move out as their real returns fell and a stronger rupee brings back such flows as real returns improve. Therefore, rupee movement and expectations of the same are very critical here. Hence the reversal of fortunes in the positive direction has taken place.
Will these good tidings last? It does look like the worst is over for oil as well as the rupee. But volatility will remain till April or so.
First, the oil producers are now at the receiving end. Oil is a zero-sum game. If consumers gain, producers lose, and vice versa. With prices now looking at even $60/barrel (WTI is already lower), there is a lot at stake and the OPEC will invoke output cuts again to keep the price steady. Clarity will emerge in December when a decision is taken.
Second, the relaxation of sanctions for specific countries including India by the US is for 6 months which means that the same issues will come to the fore as we approach April. Therefore, the story is far from over and there will be volatility. However, one can be quite confident that oil will not go beyond 70 and the rupee too will be in the 69-71 range to begin with.
The world has definitely witnessed upheaval on the oil score with output cuts, sanctions and trade wars first leading to currency depreciation and now getting reversed at one go. These trends will carry on till March 2019 for sure, but with more controlled amplitudes.
(The writer is Chief Economist, CARE Ratings; and author of Economics of India: How to fool all people for all times)
Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and news updates, sign up for our WhatsApp services. Just go to Firstpost.com/Whatsapp and hit the Subscribe button.
Updated Date: Nov 23, 2018 12:02:33 IST