Narendra Modi govt's dilemma: Should Etihad be allowed to raise its stake in Jet Airways jeopardising FDI rules or let airline fail?

Allowing Etihad to take the controls by ousting Jet Airways' founder and majority owner Naresh Goyal would make financial and strategic sense

Reuters January 17, 2019 12:18:25 IST
Narendra Modi govt's dilemma: Should Etihad be allowed to raise its stake in Jet Airways jeopardising FDI rules or let airline fail?
  • Jet Airways has been in a holding pattern since missing a repayment to banks earlier this month

  • Allowing Etihad to take the controls by ousting founder and majority owner Naresh Goyal would make financial and strategic sense

  • The alternative scenario may be to let lenders swap some debt for equity

Mumbai: Narendra Modi faces an airborne dilemma. To keep Jet Airways flying, the prime minister may have to choose between relaxing foreign ownership rules for Abu Dhabi-backer Etihad, and letting state lenders take a hit on a private carrier. Both options touch the country’s financial sore points—and represent a quandary for the ruling party ahead of the general elections due by May.

India’s second-largest airline, one of two major home-grown long-haul operators, has been in a holding pattern since missing a repayment to banks earlier this month. Etihad is willing to pump in cash to hold onto a strategic investment which feeds traffic from a market of 1.3 billion people into its own sparsely populated Gulf base. Allowing Etihad to take the controls by ousting founder and majority owner Naresh Goyal would make financial and strategic sense.

Narendra Modi govts dilemma Should Etihad be allowed to raise its stake in Jet Airways jeopardising FDI rules or let airline fail

Representational image. Reuters

But that would involve Etihad increasing its stake from 24 percent which would, in turn, trigger a requirement to launch an open offer for the rest and risk breaching rules limiting foreign carriers to owning 49 percent.

Making an exception here would be awkward, given New Delhi has been tightening the implementation of foreign investment rules elsewhere, including in e-commerce, potentially causing significant pain for Amazon and US retailer Walmart, which now controls local giant Flipkart.

The alternative scenario may be to let lenders swap some debt for equity. Jet said on Wednesday that it was in talks with stakeholders considering options including on the “debt-equity mix”. Financial institutions are rarely good owners of industrial assets, though. Indian banks look even less well-equipped, given so many of them are saddled with bad assets already, and are struggling with governance and bad loans.

Neither solution is politically palatable. Either a relaxation of foreign ownership or allowing lenders to prop up a failing private institution would provide the opposition with a stick to beat Modi in a poll that could be closely contested. But letting the airline fail isn’t an option either: that could cost thousands of jobs, and losses for banks too. There’s still hope of white knight bid from India’s biggest conglomerate, the Tata group. But the runway for Jet and the prime minister looks increasingly short.

 

 

To keep watching India’s No. 1 English Business News Channel – CNBC-TV18, call your Cable or DTH Operator and ask for the Colors Family Pack (inclusive of 24 channels), available for Rs. 35/- per month, or subscribe to the channel for Rs. 4/- per day.

To keep watching the Leader in Global Market & Business News – CNBC-TV18 Prime HD, call your Cable or DTH Operator and ask for the Colors Family HD Pack (inclusive of 25 channels), available for Rs. 50/- per month, or subscribe to the channel for Rs. 1/- per day.

Updated Date:

also read

Why Narendra Modi is a radical departure in Indian thinking about the world
India

Why Narendra Modi is a radical departure in Indian thinking about the world

The prime minister pitches India as the source of ideas, and not just as a successful implementer of ideas

At East Asia Summit, Narendra Modi reaffirms India's focus on a free, open and inclusive Indo-Pacific
India

At East Asia Summit, Narendra Modi reaffirms India's focus on a free, open and inclusive Indo-Pacific

India remains committed to strengthening respect for shared values of multilateralism, rules-based international order, international law and sovereignty and territorial integrity, said the prime minister at 16th East Asia Summit hosted by Brunei

Prime Minister Narendra Modi wishes Home Minister Amit Shah on birthday
India

Prime Minister Narendra Modi wishes Home Minister Amit Shah on birthday

Modi tweeted his greetings and lauded his contribution to the BJP and the government.