Monsanto loses legal battle over GM cotton patents; firm's false claim exposed, says National Seed Association head

On Wednesday, the Delhi High Court agreed with NSL, ruling that India’s Patent Act does not allow Monsanto any patent cover for its GM cotton seeds, said Narne Murali Krishna, a company secretary for NSL.

Reuters April 12, 2018 09:15:47 IST
Monsanto loses legal battle over GM cotton patents; firm's false claim exposed, says National Seed Association head

New Delhi: A court ruled on Wednesday that Monsanto cannot claim patents on its genetically modified (GM) cotton seeds in India, the Indian company that brought the case said.

Citing a law that excludes seeds from being patented, Nuziveedu Seeds Ltd (NSL) argued that the US seeds company was not eligible to claim patents and charge royalties from Indian seed companies.

On Wednesday, the Delhi High Court agreed with NSL, ruling that India’s Patent Act does not allow Monsanto any patent cover for its GM cotton seeds, said Narne Murali Krishna, a company secretary for NSL.

A Monsanto India spokesman said the company was “very disappointed” with the court order.

Monsanto loses legal battle over GM cotton patents firms false claim exposed says National Seed Association head

Monsanto logo. Reuters

“Today’s order will have wide-ranging, negative implications for biotech-based innovation across many sectors within India, and is inconsistent with other international markets where agricultural innovation has flourished,” the spokesman said in a statement.

Monsanto’s “false claim has got exposed today,” Kalyan Goswami, director general of the National Seed Association of India, said in a statement.

Late last year, NSL said it would not settle a long-standing intellectual property dispute with Monsanto over genetically modified cotton, despite some other Indian companies doing so.

Monsanto has been involved in a long-running battle in India over royalties paid by local seed companies for its GM cotton.

In 2016, the country's farm ministry cut Monsanto’s royalties by more than 70 percent, triggering a long-running feud that drew in the Indian and US governments.

In March, India cut the royalties paid to Monsanto for its GM cotton for the second time in two years, potentially fuelling another row with the U.S. company that threatened to leave India in 2016.

More than 90 percent of the country's cotton crop is genetically modified.

Updated Date:

also read

Monsanto pulls new GM cotton seed from India in protest
Business

Monsanto pulls new GM cotton seed from India in protest

The company is also at loggerheads with India over how much it can charge for its genetically modified cotton seeds, costing it tens of millions of dollars in lost revenue every year.

Govt cuts Monsanto's GM cotton seed royalty for second time in two years, may spark another row
Business

Govt cuts Monsanto's GM cotton seed royalty for second time in two years, may spark another row

India has cut royalties that local seed companies pay to Monsanto Co for the second time in two years, potentially fuelling another row with the US company

Genetically modified mustard no solution for India’s Rs 64,000 crore edible oil import bill, low farm income
Business

Genetically modified mustard no solution for India’s Rs 64,000 crore edible oil import bill, low farm income

Pushing farmers to grow oilseeds again will mean making the crop as attractive as cotton, one of its main competitors for requiring similar agro-climatic conditions.