Firstpost
  • Home
  • Video Shows
    Vantage Firstpost America Firstpost Africa First Sports
  • World
    US News
  • Explainers
  • News
    India Opinion Cricket Tech Entertainment Sports Health Photostories
  • Asia Cup 2025
Apple Incorporated Modi ji Justin Trudeau Trending

Sections

  • Home
  • Live TV
  • Videos
  • Shows
  • World
  • India
  • Explainers
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Cricket
  • Health
  • Tech/Auto
  • Entertainment
  • Web Stories
  • Business
  • Impact Shorts

Shows

  • Vantage
  • Firstpost America
  • Firstpost Africa
  • First Sports
  • Fast and Factual
  • Between The Lines
  • Flashback
  • Live TV

Events

  • Raisina Dialogue
  • Independence Day
  • Champions Trophy
  • Delhi Elections 2025
  • Budget 2025
  • US Elections 2024
  • Firstpost Defence Summit
Trending:
  • Nepal protests
  • Nepal Protests Live
  • Vice-presidential elections
  • iPhone 17
  • IND vs PAK cricket
  • Israel-Hamas war
fp-logo
Is Vodafone ready to blink in tax dispute with govt?
Whatsapp Facebook Twitter
Whatsapp Facebook Twitter
Apple Incorporated Modi ji Justin Trudeau Trending

Sections

  • Home
  • Live TV
  • Videos
  • Shows
  • World
  • India
  • Explainers
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Cricket
  • Health
  • Tech/Auto
  • Entertainment
  • Web Stories
  • Business
  • Impact Shorts

Shows

  • Vantage
  • Firstpost America
  • Firstpost Africa
  • First Sports
  • Fast and Factual
  • Between The Lines
  • Flashback
  • Live TV

Events

  • Raisina Dialogue
  • Independence Day
  • Champions Trophy
  • Delhi Elections 2025
  • Budget 2025
  • US Elections 2024
  • Firstpost Defence Summit
  • Home
  • Business
  • Is Vodafone ready to blink in tax dispute with govt?

Is Vodafone ready to blink in tax dispute with govt?

George Albert • December 21, 2014, 04:48:16 IST
Whatsapp Facebook Twitter

There are signs that Vodafone may be ready to compromise with the government in its tax dispute. What gives?

Advertisement
Subscribe Join Us
Add as a preferred source on Google
Prefer
Firstpost
On
Google
Is Vodafone ready to blink in tax dispute with govt?

By R Jagannathan

Despite all the bark and bluster, is Vodafone quietly trying to settle its tax case with the government through a compromise?

And if it is, why is it doing so, when everyone in the world - from the British Chancellor to the Dutch government to US Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner - has been batting for Vodafone and lobbying against the retrospective tax proposed in Pranab Mukherjee’s March budget?

Has Vodafone realised that it is not on as solid a ground as it thought after the Supreme Court ruled in its favour last January? The court held that Vodafone was not obliged to withhold capital gains tax when it bought Hutchison Essar’s Indian operations in 2007 in an all-offshore deal.

STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

A report in The Economic Times, which has no confirmations from Vodafone, suggests that the telco has indeed approached the finance minister with an offer that could include payment of the Rs 11,000-12,000 crore tax it was supposed to deduct while buying Hutchison’s Indian telecom operations. In return, Vodafone reportedly wants the government to waive penalty and interest amounting to another Rs 8,000 crore.

More from Business blogs
Explained: How Elon Musk got $44 billion to buy Twitter Explained: How Elon Musk got $44 billion to buy Twitter India in talks with different countries to make Rupay acceptable: Sitharaman India in talks with different countries to make Rupay acceptable: Sitharaman

[caption id=“attachment_294201” align=“alignleft” width=“380” caption=“The SC last January held that Vodafone was not obliged to withhold capital gains tax when it bought Hutchison Essar’s Indian operations in 2007 in an all-offshore deal.AFP”] ![](https://images.firstpost.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/vodafoneindia-afp.jpg "vodafoneindia-afp") [/caption]

The newspaper quoted an official as saying that the discussions were preliminary in nature, and thus there could be no certainty over the outcome. Such settlements could also be difficult to accept in the current political climate where any concession to a private party will spark rumours of payoffs and skullduggery.

However, the very fact that such talks are being hinted at suggest a thaw in the Vodafone position, and it is worth figuring out what the reason for it could be.

For one, even though Vodafone has invoked the Indo-Netherlands Bilateral Investment Treaty (BIT) to claim protection of its investments, there is always a question-mark over whether BIT can be invoked in a tax dispute.

Second, Indian courts have usually bowed to the executive in many cases of retrospective legislation. Hence Vodafone cannot be sure it will be second time lucky with the Supreme Court - when the fact is even the Bombay High Court found in the government’s favour before the Supreme Court finally gave it victory.

STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

Third, and this could be the real reason, Hutchison Whampoa - the company which sold the telecom operations to Vodafone - is said to be keen on returning to India for business. If this is true, then its entry would be blocked by the Vodafone case since the tax is actually payable by Hutchison, not Vodafone. Vodafone was merely supposed to deduct the tax on behalf of the Indian taxman.

In an interview last week, Finance Secretary RS Gujral hinted that paying tax may have been Vodafone’s responsibility in its deal with Hutchison. He told Business Standard: “In their own wisdom, Vodafone took a call and remitted the payment (to Hutchison) without withholding the tax. Now, what the (tax) officers, while raising the demand, have also mentioned is, according to their information, an amount higher than the final one paid by Vodafone was offered by some other party (to Hutchison). Perhaps the difference reflects the tax amount.”

STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

As _Firstpost_ noted, Gujral also said: “One can seek to conclude that Vodafone, in its agreement with Hutchison, took advantage of a lower price and said any responsibility of tax was on its account. That is why Vodafone is fighting so hard. Otherwise, in normal business transactions, if a person is a buyer, he will put a clause that if any tax is levied, the seller would be liable to pay. Clearly, it is an issue in which they took a gamble that perhaps they would be able to avoid tax, and whatever they avoid, becomes their profit.”

If Gujaral’s interpretation is correct, and if Hutch is coming back to India, Vodafone has to pay up.

Is this why Vodafone is now ready to blink in its eyeball-to-eyeball with the finance ministry? Watch this space.

Tags
Supreme Court Vodafone Group Plc Tax axe Vodafone case Hutchison Essar RS Gujral
End of Article
Written by George Albert
Email

George Albert is a Chicago-based trend watcher and edits www.capturetrends.com see more

Latest News
Find us on YouTube
Subscribe
End of Article

Top Stories

Israel targets top Hamas leaders in Doha; Qatar, Iran condemn strike as violation of sovereignty

Israel targets top Hamas leaders in Doha; Qatar, Iran condemn strike as violation of sovereignty

Nepal: Oli to continue until new PM is sworn in, nation on edge as all branches of govt torched

Nepal: Oli to continue until new PM is sworn in, nation on edge as all branches of govt torched

Who is CP Radhakrishnan, India's next vice-president?

Who is CP Radhakrishnan, India's next vice-president?

Israel informed US ahead of strikes on Hamas leaders in Doha, says White House

Israel informed US ahead of strikes on Hamas leaders in Doha, says White House

Israel targets top Hamas leaders in Doha; Qatar, Iran condemn strike as violation of sovereignty

Israel targets top Hamas leaders in Doha; Qatar, Iran condemn strike as violation of sovereignty

Nepal: Oli to continue until new PM is sworn in, nation on edge as all branches of govt torched

Nepal: Oli to continue until new PM is sworn in, nation on edge as all branches of govt torched

Who is CP Radhakrishnan, India's next vice-president?

Who is CP Radhakrishnan, India's next vice-president?

Israel informed US ahead of strikes on Hamas leaders in Doha, says White House

Israel informed US ahead of strikes on Hamas leaders in Doha, says White House

Top Shows

Vantage Firstpost America Firstpost Africa First Sports
Latest News About Firstpost
Most Searched Categories
  • Web Stories
  • World
  • India
  • Explainers
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Cricket
  • Tech/Auto
  • Entertainment
  • IPL 2025
NETWORK18 SITES
  • News18
  • Money Control
  • CNBC TV18
  • Forbes India
  • Advertise with us
  • Sitemap
Firstpost Logo

is on YouTube

Subscribe Now

Copyright @ 2024. Firstpost - All Rights Reserved

About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Cookie Policy Terms Of Use
Home Video Shorts Live TV