Infosys: Not all promoters likely to be in sync with Narayana Murthy's criticism, says advisory firm
IiAS said the voting pattern of Infosys promoters' shares in resolutions presented by the company over the past 36 months is 'unmistakable evidence' of an internal difference of opinion.
New Delhi: As a leadership crisis continues at Infosys, an investor advisory firm on Wednesday said the IT firm's founders have not always been in sync with each other and N R Narayana Murthy's public criticism of the management may not necessarily represent that of the entire promoter group.
Citing the voting pattern of promoters on various management proposals that have faced criticism in past three years, Institutional Investor Advisory Services (IiAS) said the founders have never voted against any resolution.
"In case they do not acquiesce with what the management proposes, they express their unhappiness by abstaining; all the while vocalisation their reservation," it said.
The report comes amid a tussle between some of Infosys founders, including N R Narayana Murthy, and the management over a range of issues like alleged corporate governance lapses at the firm, higher compensation paid to CEO Vishal Sikka and severance package extended to certain former executives.
Vishal Sikka, the first non-founder CEO of Infosys, resigned on 18 August from the company following months of acrimony with high-profile founders, led by N R Narayana Murthy, citing "malicious" and "personal attacks" on him.
While Sikka did not name Murthy for his exit, the board of the $10 billion firm blamed him for "continuous assault" through "factually inaccurate" and "already-disproved rumours" for the sudden resignation "despite strong board support".
Murthy, who left all board positions at Infosys before Sikka began his five-year term in August 2014, launched a counter-offensive saying that all he wanted as a shareholder was good governance and had neither questioned Sikka's work nor sought money or position for his children.
IiAS said the voting pattern of promoters' shares in resolutions presented by the company over the past 36 months is "unmistakable evidence" of an internal difference of opinion.
Not all founders vote on all resolutions suggesting that they are in not always in sync with each other, the investor advisory firm said.
"Therefore, one could well conclude that not all promoters share Narayana Murthy's concerns or even support his public criticism of the company and its board," it said.
According to IiAS, the voting over this 36-month period shows that even as the public debate over Sikka and the board's behaviour raged, another discussion was taking place, away from the bright lights.
"And just like there have been strong but opposing views regarding all decisions in public, the founders too have been at odds," IiAS added.
Infosys' ex-CFO V Balakrishnan bats for Nandan Nilekani as chairman
Balakrishnan's comments come at a time when the clamour to bring back Nilekani -- one of the most high-profile founders of the IT firm -- seems to be growing in various quarters.
As Infosys battle escalates, Ravi Venkatesan meets Arun Jaitley, Narayana Murthy sets up analyst call
Ravi Venkatesan is believed to have apprised Arun Jaitley of the developments at Infosys; Narayana Murthy is likely to clarify his part to analysts
Infosys dives 10%, market cap dips Rs 22,519 cr after Vishal Sikka quits as CEO
The steep fall in the Infosys was also instrumental in sending the 30-share benchmark index down by 270.78 points at 31,524.68