Good management: US cos retain global crown, Indian firms poorly run

The research found Brazil and China were slightly ahead of India with scores on an average of 2.67. The study however, took pains to point out that even bottom-ranking India has firms that boast world-class management practices.<br /><br />

Uttara Choudhury January 23, 2014 11:49:49 IST
Good management: US cos retain global crown, Indian firms poorly run

New York: When it comes to good management the US is on the top of the world followed by Germany, Japan, Sweden and Canada, while China's tail of poorly run firms is shorter than India's, says a study by Stanford University professor Nicholas Bloom and John Van Reenen of the London School of Economics.

Bloom and Van Reenen have focused on three boilerplate management techniques - setting targets, rewarding performance and measuring results - and weighed the performance of over 10,000 firms in 20 countries against these three metrics. The Economist reported that 150 researchers have been employed to "guarantee the robustness" of the ongoing study's results.

Good management US cos retain global crown Indian firms poorly run

Representational Image. Reuters

"American firms are incredibly well-managed on our chart. They have the best management practices in the world," Bloom told Fox Business News Network.

"There's been a lot of pessimism around America losing its global crown, and that the 21st century will be the Chinese century, but the US has a massive advantage. Businesses are creative, innovative and also incredibly well-managed, making a lot of money at home and abroad," Bloom told the network.

The researchers say the US has the highest management practice scores on average, followed by Germany, Japan, Sweden, and Canada; trailed by a block of mid-European countries - France, Italy, Ireland, the United Kingdom, and Poland - and Australia. At the bottom, are Greece and Portugal, along with developing countries like Brazil, China, and India.

Messrs Bloom and company earlier looked at how a sample of 695 randomly chosen US manufacturing ?rms with 100 to 5,000 employees stacked up against 620 similarly sized Indian ones in the textile industry.

"The results reveal a thick tail of badly run Indian ?rms, leading to a lower average management score (2.69 for India versus 3.33 for US ?rms). Indian ?rms tend not to collect and analyze data systematically in their factories, they tend not to set and monitor clear targets for performance, and they do not explicitly link pay or promotion with performance," wrote Bloom, Benn Eifert, Aprajit Mahajan, David McKenzie and John Roberts in The Quarterly Journal of Economics.

The research found Brazil and China were slightly ahead of India with scores on an average of 2.67. The study however, took pains to point out that even bottom-ranking India has firms that boast world-class management practices.

Bloom says good managers collect data and analyze it frequently to spot problems, before they get out of control. He also pointed out that incentives are what separate the US from countries like Japan or India. Bloom says in Japan, employees are usually promoted based on tenure, rather than on performance alone, which he says is unfavorable.

"Good performers should get noticed and rewarded. Data should be used to evaluate people for pay increases and promotions," Bloom told Fox Business News Network.

Updated Date:

also read

Amid war in Ukraine, a ‘barbed wire curtain’ rises in Europe
World

Amid war in Ukraine, a ‘barbed wire curtain’ rises in Europe

Earlier this month, Polish soldiers began laying coils of razor wire on the border with Kaliningrad, a Russian exclave wedged between Poland and Lithuania. Cameras and an electronic monitoring system also will be installed in the area that once was guarded only by occasional patrols of border guards

Caught in graft allegations, Hungary PM Orban puts on hold approval of Finland, Sweden's accession to NATO
India

Caught in graft allegations, Hungary PM Orban puts on hold approval of Finland, Sweden's accession to NATO

EU member Hungary is in talks with Brussels to unlock billions of euros in EU funding currently held over corruption concerns. Opposition parties have accused Orban of blackmailing the EU by putting the approval on hold

FIFA World Cup: Spirited Japan pull off incredible comeback to stun Germany 2-1
Football

FIFA World Cup: Spirited Japan pull off incredible comeback to stun Germany 2-1

Substitutes Ritsu Doan and Takuma Asano scored in a space of eight minutes to guide Japan to a memorable win after Ilkay Gundogan's penalty had put the Germans ahead at halftime.