Carlos Ghosn jailbreak is all-purpose face-saver; exit ends embarrassing diplomatic affair for Tokyo, France and former employers

Carlos Ghosn had some success positioning himself as a victim of a legal system with a 99 percent conviction rate

Reuters December 31, 2019 12:18:43 IST
Carlos Ghosn jailbreak is all-purpose face-saver; exit ends embarrassing diplomatic affair for Tokyo, France and former employers
  • Japanese prosecutors sought to deny Carlos Ghosn’s bail requests, arguing that he posed a flight risk

  • Ghosn had some success positioning himself as a victim of a legal system with a 99 percent conviction rate

  • If he had been found guilty, Ghosn—who turns 66 in March—might have died in prison, proclaiming his innocence.

Hong Kong: It’s a face-saving escape. Carlos Ghosn’s Tokyo jailbreak will spare many embarrassments. The former boss of the Nissan-Renault automotive alliance, awaiting trial on charges of financial misconduct, skipped a $9 million bail bond and popped up in Lebanon. How he evaded his minders is a story still to be told, but his exit lets Tokyo, Paris, and his former employers end a mutually embarrassing diplomatic affair.

Japanese prosecutors will be furious, at least in public. They sought to deny Ghosn’s bail requests, arguing that he posed a flight risk. And yet Ghosn had some success positioning himself as a victim of a legal system with a 99 percent conviction rate, one which had him locked in an unheated cell for months hoping to extract a confession. If he had been found guilty, Ghosn—who turns 66 in March—might have died in prison, proclaiming his innocence.

Carlos Ghosn jailbreak is allpurpose facesaver exit ends embarrassing diplomatic affair for Tokyo France and former employers

File photo of former Nissan chairman Carlos Ghosn. AP

For Nissan Motor, a trial would have cast an ugly light on weak corporate governance that let Ghosn get away with alleged infractions. The $25 billion carmaker, still struggling to execute a business turnaround, would have seen its image damaged no matter the trial outcome. For its alliance partner Renault, the ruckus has upended negotiations over mooted mergers with Nissan and with Fiat Chrysler.

The case also stung diplomatic relations: Japan and France both see the respective car companies as important components of industrial strategy. And yet Emmanuel Macron’s government, which prefers closer ties between Nissan and Renault, had to allow for the possibility that Japanese prosecutors had a strong case against Ghosn. His lacklustre management of Nissan in recent years made him a dubious advocate for French interests anyway.

Now the man, easily the most recognisable gaijin executive in Japan, has managed to dodge police surveillance and end up in a country without an extradition treaty with Japan. Prosecutors can claim his flight admits guilt. He says he “escaped injustice and political persecution” from a system that denies basic human rights. So long as Ghosn stays out of France, corporate and diplomatic scars can start healing, and everyone can get back to work.

Updated Date:

also read

Budget 2022: How corporate governance will take centre stage in 2022
Business

Budget 2022: How corporate governance will take centre stage in 2022

The year 2022 will be marked by increased adoption of technology and digital transformation

France officially bans LGBTQ ‘conversion therapy’: What you need to know
World

France officially bans LGBTQ ‘conversion therapy’: What you need to know

France joined US, Germany, Canada and other countries as it passed a law criminalising the use of the discredited practice to attempt to change the sexual orientation or gender identity of gay people