Boeing assumptions on 737 MAX emergency response faulted: NTSB

By David Shepardson WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Boeing Co failed to adequately consider how pilots respond to cockpit emergencies in its 737 MAX safety assessment and may need to make changes to flight deck alerts, pilot procedures and training, the National Transportation Safety Board said. The U.S

Reuters September 27, 2019 04:06:57 IST
Boeing assumptions on 737 MAX emergency response faulted: NTSB

Boeing assumptions on 737 MAX emergency response faulted NTSB

By David Shepardson

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Boeing Co failed to adequately consider how pilots respond to cockpit emergencies in its 737 MAX safety assessment and may need to make changes to flight deck alerts, pilot procedures and training, the National Transportation Safety Board said.

The U.S. air accident investigator unveiled on Thursday several recommendations to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) following the fatal crashes of a Lion Air 737 MAX in Indonesia and an Ethiopian Airlines 737 MAX five months apart that killed a total of 346 people. The crashes led to the plane's grounding and raised questions about the FAA's certification of the new aircraft.

The crews in those crashes "did not react in the ways Boeing and the FAA assumed they would,” said NTSB Chairman Robert Sumwalt, adding there was a "gap between the assumptions used to certify the MAX and the real-world experiences of these crews, where pilots were faced with multiple alarms and alerts at the same time."

Boeing has said the feeding of erroneous Angle of Attack (AOA) data to a system called MCAS that pushed the planes lower was a common link in two wider chains of events leading to the crashes. MCAS stands for Manoeuvring Characteristics Augmentation System.

"We want FAA to ensure that Boeing takes a close look at all these different failure conditions that can activate MCAS and ensure that they have evaluated the pilots' response to that," Dana Schulze, director of the NTSB Office of Aviation Safety, told reporters. NTSB wants that assessment completed before the plane's grounding is lifted.

Boeing's 737 MAX simulator tests with test pilots "did not look at all potential flight deck alerts and indications that pilots might face when this specific failure condition occurred in Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines," Schulze said, adding that Boeing did not evaluate the "actual scenario" of the two fatal crashes in the simulator.

Boeing should "more clearly and concisely inform pilots of the highest priority actions when multiple flight deck alerts and indications are present," the NTSB said.

U.S. House of Representatives Transportation Committee chairman Peter DeFazio said on Thursday that the NTSB report suggests Boeing "may not have made realistic assumptions about how pilots respond to multiple simultaneous and potentially confusing warnings in emergency situations."

"Commercial airplanes should be able to be safely flown by an appropriately-trained pilot on his or her worst day," DeFazio added.

The FAA said in a statement it "will carefully review these and all other recommendations as we continue our review of the proposed changes to the Boeing 737 MAX."

Boeing, in a statement, said it is "committed to working with the FAA in reviewing the NTSB recommendations."

'WAKE-UP CALL'

Robert Clifford, the lead lawyer for families of victims of the Ethiopian Airlines crash who are suing Boeing, said the recommendations should be "a wake-up call" for the FAA "to put these measures into effect as soon as possible."

The NTSB said the FAA should address assumptions Boeing and other manufacturers make in designing software systems to react to emergencies, and whether the systems should be revised to account for varying pilot reactions to cockpit alarms and alerts.

The safety board also said the FAA should develop "robust tools and methods" to validate assumptions about pilot response.

Boeing is revising the 737 MAX software to require the MCAS system to receive input from both AOA sensors, and has added additional safeguards.

The report came a day after Boeing's board said it had created a new permanent safety committee to oversee development, manufacturing and operation of its aircraft and services.

The NTSB said it was not analysing pilot actions in the two fatal crashes and that the recommendations were not a reflection on the pilots in those crashes.

Boeing's 737 MAX safety system assessments assumed "immediate and appropriate pilot corrective actions in response to uncommanded flight control inputs, from systems such as MCAS," the NTSB said. It should take into account how other possible flight deck alerts and other factors could impact pilots' decision making and makes changes as warranted, the agency added.

The NTSB said it wants the FAA to require the same assessment for all other airplane manufacturers and believes other international regulators that certify airplanes should consider making the same changes.

It is not clear when Boeing will conduct a key certification test flight, a step needed before the FAA can return the plane to service. The company has said it hopes to resume flights early in the fourth quarter.

The FAA said last week it will need a month after the test flight is completed before it could allow flights to resume.

(Reporting by David Shepardson; Editing by Muralikumar Anantharaman and Bill Berkrot)

This story has not been edited by Firstpost staff and is generated by auto-feed.

Updated Date:

TAGS:

Find latest and upcoming tech gadgets online on Tech2 Gadgets. Get technology news, gadgets reviews & ratings. Popular gadgets including laptop, tablet and mobile specifications, features, prices, comparison.

also read

Moderna raises 2021 vaccine output forecast to at least 600 million doses
World

Moderna raises 2021 vaccine output forecast to at least 600 million doses

(Reuters) -Moderna Inc said on Monday it would produce at least 600 million doses of its COVID-19 vaccine in 2021, up by 100 million doses from its previous forecast, as the United States continues to roll-out the vaccine. The company was working to invest and hire in order to deliver up to 1 billion doses this year, the higher end of its production forecast, it said

On thin ice? Poles get creative to skate round coronavirus rules
World

On thin ice? Poles get creative to skate round coronavirus rules

WARSAW (Reuters) - A skating rink owner in the Polish city of Szczecin believes he has found a way to keep his business open despite coronavirus restrictions - operate as a flower shop instead. His plan is simple - the customer has to purchase access to the flower "warehouse", then chooses from a box of flowers in the middle of the rink. "You can jump, crawl or go on all fours ..

Yemeni boy, ravaged by hunger, weighs 7 kg
World

Yemeni boy, ravaged by hunger, weighs 7 kg

By Reuters Staff SANAA (Reuters) - Paralysed and severely malnourished, seven-year-old Faid Samim lies curled up on a hospital bed in the Yemeni capital Sanaa, having barely survived the journey there.  "He was almost gone when he arrived but thank God we were able to do what was necessary and he started improving. He is suffering from CP (cerebral palsy) and severe malnutrition," said Rageh Mohammed, the supervising doctor of the Al-Sabeen hospital's malnutrition ward.