What to expect from PM Modi's visit to Japan: Civilian nuclear deal, maritime security - Firstpost
Firstpost
You are here:

What to expect from PM Modi's visit to Japan: Civilian nuclear deal, maritime security


During the visit of Japanese Prime Minister Shinjo Abe to India in December 2015, a joint statement on 'India and Japan Vision 2025: Special Strategic and Global Partnership Working Together for Peace and Prosperity of the Indo-Pacific Region and the World' was issued.

This vision encompassed a deep, broad-based and action-oriented partnership, acknowledging congruence of political, economic and strategic interests and capability of responding to global and regional challenges. Among the takeaways, was signing the MoU for Japan’s High Speed Railways (HSR) technologies (the Shinkansen system) for the Mumbai-Ahmedabad route.

modi abet--621x414

India PM Modi and Japan PM Abe. Image from PTI

Trilateral dialogues between Japan-India-US have been ongoing and inaugural trialogue between Japan-India-Australia has also taken place. These mechanisms could contribute to regional efforts to evolve an open, inclusive and stable economic, political and security architecture in the Indo-Pacific region.

Japanese Defence Minister Gen Nakatani visited India in July 2016 after the Malabar 2016 exercise held in Western Pacific in which Indian, Japanese and US Navies participated.

A major preceding occurrence was ruling by Hague-based Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) on the Philippines versus China case; ruling in favour of Philippines, negating China’s so called historical claims in South China Sea (SCS) and censuring China for her illegal activities in the SCS.

Both Defence Minister Parrikar and General Nakatani urged all parties to show utmost respect for UNCLOS, reaffirming the importance of respecting international law, as reflected notably in the UNCLOS, need for peaceful settlement of all disputes without any threat or use of force, and of ensuring freedom and safety of navigation and over-flight as well as unimpeded lawful commerce in international waters.

India and Japan have been holding exchanges and talks at military-to-military level, and information exchanges on maritime data, both countries being prominent maritime states in the Indo-Pacific. There has been agreement on technology transfer and protection of military information, a framework for collaboration in field of defence in high-tech areas is being looked at.

India identifies Japan as privileged partner in the ‘Make in India’ program and an important strategic partner in its ‘Act East Policy’. The India-Japan Civilian Nuclear Deal is one of the crucial elements of cooperation in the Indo-Japanese relationship. A MoU exists between Indian Coast Guard and Japan Coast Guard for Establishment of a Collaborative Relationship to Combat Crimes at Sea and Develop Regional Cooperation.

Ahead of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Japan on 11-12 November, the Japanese Foreign Ministry spokesperson have been saying that Tokyo is encouraging India to speak up more on South China Sea disputes.

There is no doubt that China's growing assertiveness in East China Sea (ECS), particularly China’s use of civilian boat militias to challenge Japan's sovereignty over the Senkaku Islands has created added tension in the region. Interestingly, when a Chinese panelist at a recent international seminar at New Delhi was questioned about China using civilian boat-militia storming Senkaku Islands, he denied government involvement, adding, “maybe Chinese fishermen want more fish”.

But as far as Japanese Foreign Ministry encouraging India more to speak up more on SCS disputes, our MEA spokesman has already clearly and categorically stated that India respects the UNCLOS judgment and calls for greater openness of the international seas and trading routes and no single nation can hold hegemony over it. This not only includes South China Sea but entire Indo-Pacific region.

One major issue during Prime Minister Modi’s third summit with PM Abe would be the India-Japan Civilian Nuclear Deal, under discussion since 2008. Though Japanese media indicates the agreement could be signed during the forthcoming summit, Japanese officials have been non-committal about it beyond saying that the agreement is being looked at from the legal angle. Whether this will be concluded before PM Modi’s visit is not confirmed.

However, during the visit of PM Abe to India in December 2015, the initial agreement had noted the need to complete “necessary internal procedures”. The implication of this is that even after India and Japan sign the civil-nuclear agreement, for it to come into effect it must be approved by the Japanese Parliament (Diet). Japan’s Diet has always been sensitive to anything connected with nuclear, understandably being the only country having been subjected to nuclear attack, that too twice – at Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

Interestingly in 1994, then Japanese Prime Minister Tsutomu Hata had stated in the Diet that Japan has the knowhow to make the nuclear bomb. His government fell after one week.

Another major takeaway from Modi’s visit is likely to be a deal worth some Rs 10,000 crores for Japan to supply India with 12 x US-2i amphibious aircraft. This is featuring both in Indian and Japanese media. India plans to equip the Indian Navy and Indian Coast Guard with six each of these aircraft. Japan has reportedly agreed to reduce the price, earlier pegged at $1.6 billion (Rs 10,720 crore) for the 12 aircraft, to clinch the deal and expand its strategic partnership with India.

The four turbo-prop US-2i is capable of short take-offs from land or water. Meant for search and rescue, it can also transport 30 combat troops. Interestingly, Japan had proposed in mid 1990s positioning 2 x US-2i amphibious aircraft in Andaman & Nicobar for search and rescue at sea. The Japanese proposal was free of cost with both the amphibious aircraft to under joint control of India and Japan, and to be operated jointly by both countries. Ironically, India did not respond and two decades later we are buying the same aircraft.

Maritime security too would be an obvious focus area during the upcoming summit, considering the growing assertiveness of China and her clear denouncement of global norms and laws.

Peace and prosperity in the Indo-Pacific is vital to both India and Japan. But while Japan seeks more focus on maritime security cooperation in its bilateral and multilateral engagements including with India, at the same time it must also push the India-Japan-Civil-Nuclear Deal past the Diet and bring it to early implementation.

There is also plenty scope and mutual gain for both countries to bond in areas like nuclear engineering, cyberspace, space, power generation, 3D printing with robotics and other technological collaboration for coping with emerging threats.

First Published On : Nov 9, 2016 10:28 IST

Comment using Disqus

Show Comments