You are here:

Harvard removes Swamy-taught courses, citing his piece

by FP Staff  Dec 8, 2011 09:33 IST

#Harvard University   #Janata Party   #Subramanian Swamy   #WhatNext  

New York: Harvard University has decided to remove courses taught by Janata Party president Subramanian Swamy at its annual summer school session, terming his views as "reprehensible" in a controversial piece he wrote on Islamic terrorism in India.

At a meeting of Harvard's Faculty of Arts and Sciences, faculty members voted with an "overwhelming majority" to remove two economics courses - 'Quantitative Methods in Economics and Business' and 'Economic Development in India and East Asia' - that Swamy teaches at the three-month Harvard Summer School session.

The faculty meeting, convened to approve the 2012 Summer School course catalogue, resulted in a "heated debate" when Comparative Religion Professor Diana Eck proposed an amendment to exclude Swamy's courses from the catalogue, the Harvard Crimson reported.

In a July op-ed piece for an Indian publication, Swamy had recommended demolishing hundreds of mosques and suggested that only Muslims in India who "acknowledge that their ancestors were Hindus" should be allowed to vote.

Eck said Swamy's op-ed "clearly crosses the line by demonising an entire religious community and calling for violence against their sacred places," adding that Harvard has a moral responsibility not to affiliate itself with anyone who expresses hatred towards a minority group.

"There is a distinction between unpopular and unwelcome political views," Eck said.

Earlier, more than 400 students had signed a petition calling for Swamy's removal after Harvard had decided to stand by him, affirming its commitment to free speech principles.

Dean of Summer School Donald Pfister said courses included in the catalogue are chosen by individual departments.

"I find (Swamy's) position reprehensible, but on the other hand, it is our duty to support departments and their offerings," he said.

Philosophy Department Chair Sean Kelly had initially defended the unanimous decision of Harvard's Faculty Council to keep Swamy on the teaching roster as an effort to preserve free speech at the school. Kelly ultimately voted for the amendment to remove Swamy's courses.

"I was persuaded ... that the views expressed in Dr Swamy's op-ed piece amounted to incitement of violence instead of protected political speech," he said.

Harvard had chosen to stand by Swamy in August in line with its declared commitment to free speech. However at Tuesday's meeting, faculty members agreed to remove his two courses, effectively removing him from Harvard's teaching roster. Faculty members said Swamy's article was not a product of free speech—but of hate speech.

Reuters

"(Swamy's position on disenfranchisement) is like saying Jewish Americans and African Americans should not be allowed to vote unless they acknowledge the supremacy of white Anglo Saxon Protestants," said History Professor Sugata Bose.

After Swamy's controversial piece appeared, a group of Harvard students known as 'Coalition Against Bigotry at Harvard' had started a petition drive calling on the University to severe ties with him.

The Janata Party leader had received his PhD in Economics from Harvard in 1965 and has served as an assistant and associate professor.

Division of Continuing Education spokesperson Linda Cross had called the article "distressing" but had said "it is central to the mission of a university to protect free speech, including that of Dr Swamy and of those who disagree with him."

Subramanian Swamy has said that the decision by Harvard university to discontinue his classes is a "dangerous principle that stifles personal opinion". Commenting on the decision on his personal twitter feed Swamy said, "I have been held accountable at Harvard for what I write in India.This means India studies' Witzel and Eck are accountable in India. Healthy?"  Witzel and Eck are professors at Harvard.

At a meeting of Harvard’s Faculty of Arts and Sciences, faculty members voted with an “overwhelming majority” to remove two economics courses – ‘Quantitative Methods in Economics and Business’ and ‘Economic Development in India and East Asia’ – that Swamy teaches at the three-month Harvard Summer School session. In a statement after the decision was announced, the university said that the views expressed in Dr Swamy’s op-ed piece in the DNA newspaperamounted to incitement of violence instead of protected political speech,” he said.

Harvard had initially chosen to stand by Swamy in line with its declared commitment to free speech. However at Tuesday’s meeting, faculty members agreed to remove his two courses, effectively removing him from Harvard’s teaching roster. Faculty members said Swamy’s article was not a product of free speech—but of hate speech.

Swamy however remained defiant, saying that the dangerous thing Harvard has done is to make their Professors responsible for what they write anywhere in the world adding "IIT/D sacked me in 1973. Four years later, I became a member of the IIT Board Governors--the very body which had sacked me!"

with inputs from PTI

Watch video

NEW EBOOK