Apple: iPhones created design crisis for Samsung

Apple Inc trotted out a veteran designer to bolster its claims that Samsung Electronics copied the iPhone, after the smartphone's 2007 launch triggered a "crisis in design" for the South Korean electronics giant. Lawyers for Apple showed an internal Samsung document that likened the look of their rival gadgets to "Heaven and Earth."  But Samsung strategy chief Justin Denison called that kind of language "hyperbole," saying it sounded like something senior executives would have used to motivate and energize employees. "What we would like to be able to do is just compete in the market," Denison said. Asked by Apple attorney Bill Lee whether there was a difference between competing "fairly and squarely" and taking someone else's intellectual property, he said: "Yes."

The trial goes on

iOS devices and Samsung Galaxy line up substantially the same



Apple later called Peter Bressler, a college professor with electronics design experience and some 70 patents to his name, who analyzed a number of Samsung Galaxy gadgets and the iPhone and iPad. They were "substantially the same", said Bressler, who lectures at the University of Pennsylvania and founded the design firm Bressler Group. He has worked with clients including Motorola in the past.


"The aesthetics they (Apple) were trying to achieve were particularly difficult and expensive," said Bressler, who said he read numerous depositions of Apple employees and discovered the company employed special machine processes, for instance. Apple and Samsung are going toe-to-toe in a high-wattage patents dispute, which mirrors a fierce battle for industry supremacy between two rivals that control more than half of worldwide smartphone sales.


Bressler examined a number of gadgets, Apple's patents on file, and even a Wired article before forming his conclusion that Samsung had borrowed multiple Apple design elements. But under cross-examination from Samsung's lawyer, he said consumers ultimately were unlikely to confuse the two brands -- a key contention in the case.


The U.S. company accuses Samsung of copying the design and some features of its iPad and iPhone, and is asking for billions of dollars in damages and sales bans. The Korean company, which is trying to expand in the U.S. market, says Apple infringed some of its key wireless technology patents.


The trial began last week and has already granted Silicon Valley an unprecedented peek behind the curtain of Apple's famously secretive design and marketing machine.


On Friday, lawyers showed Apple Vice President Eddy Cue urging then-Chief Operating Officer Tim Cook in January 2011 to build a mini-iPad because he believed there was a market for a seven-inch tablet. Late co-founder Steve Jobs was "receptive" to the idea, according to Cue's email, fanning speculation Apple plans to make a mini-iPad to take on cheaper gadgets from Google Inc and Amazon .



Published Date: Aug 07, 2012 09:31 am | Updated Date: Aug 07, 2012 09:31 am