You are here: Home » Debates
poll question
Nitish Kumar's 'Bihar Model' is worth following

Votes: 28455

During his Adhikar rally, Bihar Chief Minister, Nitish Kumar spoke of the development model of Bihar as the ideal one. Is Kumar's so called model worth following?
Defending the motion


Why are we so reluctant to give Nitish Kumar his due? Here’s a man who has delivered a consistent 12 percent growth over the last five years. He has revived a state in a state of collapse and made i t count among the best governed in the country. Better still, his growth is inclusive, sensitive to all sections of the society. His success story is not flawless, but do we have any other success story in the country which is not flawless, including that of Gujarat? The worshippers of high GDP numbers should be applauding him. What we find instead is vehement criticism for him from this section. Clearly, something is amiss.
Read less

Read more

Against the motion


The so-called “inclusivist” element in the UPA or Bihar model is really a socio-political arrangement, where the benefits of growth are supposed to be shared through quotas and other such devices , even though they may be socially and politically divisive. Can a development model work if it is only based on handouts from the Centre? And, even assuming some grants help alleviate poverty, what is special status really about? As things stand, we can only see the politics of the Bihar model, not its economics.
Read less

Read more