You are here: Home » Debates
poll question
Gadkari has lost control of the BJP

Votes: 1876

As the feud in Rajasthan BJP ensues, with Vasundara Raje and 56 loyalists threatened to resign the state party, the BJP president Nitin Gadkari is in a peculiar situation of crossing swords with state leaders too often.
Defending the motion


The challenge thrown up by Vijaya Raje Scindia to Gadkari’s leadership is only the latest in a series of failures for the BJP president. He has faced problems with others, including BS Yeddyurappa i n Karnataka, and Narendra Modi in Gujarat. In a party where state leaders are stronger than the central command, Gadkari stands no chance of holding his own. Gadkari is a technocrat, and would make a good and efficient minister anywhere. But he is not No 1 material. He has neither the charisma nor the political clout to make sure his writ runs.
Read less

Read more

Against the motion


Gadkari hasn’t been a national leader before but there’s a good reason why he is still the BJP President despite dissent from state leaders. He has the support of the RSS which finally holds the r eins in the BJP. For example with BS Yeddyurappa in Karnataka, Gadkari has been keeping him on hold despite his numerous threats and hasn’t been afraid to ensure his writ is followed. Gadkari hasn’t lost hold of the party but perhaps needs to publicly reassert himself more.
Read less

Read more