Battle of the exes? Deepika's 'Piku' overshadows Ranbir's 'Bombay Velvet' at box office

New Delhi: Ranbir Kapoor-starrer Bombay Velvet has failed to displace Deepika Padukone’s simple, subtle and meaningful act as a dutiful daughter in Piku, box office figures suggest. “A colossal flop”, “a debacle”, “a disaster” are some of the verdicts by film trade analysts on Anurag Kashyap’s high-budget drama “Bombay Velvet”, which is set in the Bombay of the 1960s and about a man who wants to make it big in life at any cost. The film has earned a little over Rs.16 crore in its opening weekend. [caption id=“attachment_2233924” align=“alignleft” width=“380”]  Deepika Padukone and Amitabh Bachchan in a promotional poster for Piku.[/caption] Released on May 15, the film, which also stars Anushka Sharma and has marked the acting debut of Karan Johar, only managed to mint Rs.5.20 crore on its opening day and Rs.5.10 crore and Rs.5.80 crore on Saturday and Sunday respectively. Its weekend total amounts to Rs.16.10 crore, according to trade expert Taran Adarsh, who on Twitter called the film a “debacle”. “It’s very bad. Bombay Velvet earned just 16.25 crore. That should have been the day 1 collection instead of the weekend collection,” trade analyst Komal Nahta told IANS. “But you can’t compare Bombay Velvet to other films because of its budget of Rs.108 crore. With that amount, it should have collected Rs.15 crore on day 1. The film is a colossal flop,” he added. Another film expert, Vinod Mirani said “Bombay Velvet is a disaster”. However, Kashyap has no regrets that the audience is not finding a connect with his film, which has been his dream project since nine years. “A lot of people do not connect with it and a small number of people did… Maybe our experimenting with the narrative didn’t work for most but I firmly believe in the film,” he posted on his Facebook page. The one film which has continued its success story is Shoojit Sircar’s slice-of-life entertainer Piku, which has Amitabh Bachchan, Irrfan Khan and Deepika telling an endearing family tale through their lovable characters. Piku is running successfully at the cinemas and has minted Rs.14.60 crore in its second weekend, which takes its total collection to Rs.56.02 crore. In its opening weekend, it minted over Rs.25 crore. Also, the film is being tagged as a hit overseas as it has earned $4.3 million (Rs.27.34 crore). In fact, Adarsh has called Piku the “biggest hit of 2015 in Overseas”. As far as the future of Bombay Velvet and Piku on the box office is concerned, it will be decided by Kangana Ranaut and R. Madhavan-starrer Tanu Weds Manu Returns, which has quite a positive buzz about it. Directed by Anand L. Rai, the film, which stars the same cast from 2011 film Tanu Weds Manu, will release on Friday. IANS